Articles about William Buchholz second trial for the murder of Johann Heinrich Schulte in the New Haven Evening Register, from February and March 1880.
These articles were transcribed through a combination of automation and manual corrections. The original articles are absolutely rife with errors -- spelling, grammar, even word substitutions. In general I'm transcribing as-is, but some cases were so egregious I couldn't help myself from fixing them.
It's also worth noting that the Register had the habit of printing stories from yesterday's final edition, or possibly abbreviated versions of them, in the next day's paper. I suspect this was a consequence of the fact that it was an evening paper, so the afternoon sessions of the court were covered in the next day's paper. In any case, there are sometimes two stories on this trial in one paper, and their ordering wasn't always clear to me.
The Buchholz's Trial.
A map of the scene and surroundings of the Schulte murder is being made by Charles F. Bollman, of counsel for the defence. The distant [sic] and various points of interest are clearly indicated. There has been some important evidence discovered for the accused, but of course it is not to be divulged until the new trial, which is expected to come on next month. This expectation has been directed to every successive month following the last hearing.
The acquittal of "Cove" Bennet and Mrs. Smith, Saturday, of the charge of murdering Policeman Smith of Jersey City, inclines one to believe that hanging is really "played out" everywhere except in the South and West. Bennett and Mrs. Smith were convicted at the last trial. An error in the judge's charge gave them a new trial. The trial acquits them of murder. Buchholz gets a new trial at Bridgeport for the carelessness of a juror. The prompt acquittal of Buchholz is the only thing needed to make of justice a complete farce.
The Buchholz Trial.
The trial of William Buchholz for the murder of H. Schulte, at Norwalk, December 27, 1878, commenced at Bridgeport, Tuesday. Chief Justice Park presides, with Judge Loomis as associate. At the hour of adjournment no jurors had been obtained. An extra panel was summoned for this morning, and the day was occupied in efforts to secure a jury.
BEGINNING THE TRIAL
----------
OF THE CASE AGAINST BUCHHOLZ
----------
For the Murder of John H. Schulte, the Norwalk Miser – A Jury all of Farmers – A Former Servant of the Dead Man on the Stand – Was Schulte Attacked in Germany?
BRIDGEPORT, Feb. 19. – A jury in the Schulte case was obtained this morning, and the trial was begun. The jury is composed entirely of farmers, as follows: William D. Gregory, Wilton; Victor H. Russell, Greenwich; Frederick B. Knapp, Greenwich; George S. Bates, Darien; James N. Lake, Newtown; Edwin P. White, Ridgefield; Edwin Morehouse, Wilton; Thomas T. Bristol, Brookfield; Henry I. Bronson, Huntington; Ferdinand W. Bust, Ridgefield; Bradley Hull, Weston.
The first witness called by States Attorney Olmstead was Siegfried Grümwald, who came to this country as the servant of the murdered man, September 27, 1878. He now lives in Brooklyn where he works as a barber. It was in Dortmund, Germany, that he first met Schulte, and did so because of an advertisement to the effect that a gentleman about to cross the Atlantic to this country wanted a servant who would accompany him. He and Schulte made a contract in writing and both signed it, by which he agreed to accompany Schulte to this country and return, going in the same vessel with him. The witness said he had the contract at his house in Brooklyn now. When the two landed in New York they went to the Sonne Hotel and stayed four or five days. While there Grumwald acted as Schulte's servant, but did nothing for him, but he had to go wherever his master went. While they were stopping at the hotel the witness first saw Buchholz and had a conversation with him about Schulte.
The witness was asked whether he said anything about leaving Schulte's employ while at the hotel, and said he did; that he said that he was going to leave because Schulte was such a queer old fellow. The witness was not further questioned on this point, but it is known that he left Schulte's employ because he could not stand the eccentricities of the old miser. Schulte required that Grümwald should sleep in some room with him, and was in the habit of calling out to him every few minutes during the night to see whether he was awake or not, and he would frequently make him get up out of bed to see what time it was. When Grumwald came to leave Schulte's employ at the close of the stay at the hotel Schulte made some trouble about paying him, and settled only when Grumwald called in a policeman.
State's Attorney Olmstead attempted to show by the witness that Buchholz knew that on the 27th of December, 1878, Schulte went to New York to see Grümwald, to get him to enter his service again; that Buchholz had been discharged, and Grümwald was to be his successor. The Witness said that Schulte came to where he lived, 436 East Fifteenth street, on that day. He (witness) had previously written a letter to Schulte. Counsel for the defense objected to the line of testimony, claiming that what occurred between Schulte and Grumwald at New York was not material. Only what was communicated to Buchholz could be shown.
The court sustained the objection. The witness identified a large number of articles put in evidence as formerly belonging to Schulte. A gold watch went in as exhibit "No. 1." A watch guard with watch keys attached was also identified.
"How was Schulte dressed when he came to see you?"
The witness (through the interpreter) – "Light pants, green hat and red boots."
Two soled and worn pocketbooks were identified as once the property of the murdered man. Witness corrected a former statement to the effect that Schulte had a $1,000 bill; he should have said a bill for a 1,000 marks. The coat and hat worn by Schulte on the 27th of December, 1878, were identified by the witness, as was also the handkerchief he wore about his neck, his trunk keys, and other articles.
Mr. Olmstead – Was that stain on the handkerchief about his neck on the 27th of December that you see here now?
The witness did not know.
Mr. Olmstead – What did Schulte wear, boots or shoes?
The Witness – Laced shoes.
Some nails were shown the witness, and he said they looked like those which Schulte wore in the soles of one of his pair of shoes.
General William Randel Smith cross examined the witness, who said he first saw Schulte about August 3, 1878, a month or more before he went to live with him. Before entering his service he lived about forty minutes ride on an ordinary train from where Schulte lived. He knew that Schulte had a brother, but did not know that he had a wife
General Smith – Were you in Schulte's employ at the time when he was attacked for his life?
Objected to on the ground that there had been no evidence that Schulte was ever attacked in Germany.
Gen. Smith altered his question to: Were you in Schulte's service at the time when a party of five men, including his brother's son, fired into his bed room?
Objected to and ruled out.
Gen. Smith – Did Schulte have the reputation in Germany of being a very rich man?
Objected to and withdrawn.
Gen. Smith – What was the nature of your services for Schulte?
Witness – I was always to go with him here and there and sleep in the same room with him.
The witness said he told Buchholz that Schulte was very rich. He told others in the hotel the same thing. He didn't tell them all because he didn't know them all. The pocketbooks identified were carried by Schulte in his coat-tail pockets. The witness saw Schulte count his money, being alone with him at such times. There were several at the hotel, besides Buchholz, who knew I was going to leave Schulte's service.
The state is represented by State Attorney Olmstead and Taylor: the defense by Gen. Wm. Randel Smith of Norwalk and Mr. Bollman of this city. It is thought this trial will not be as lengthy as the first trial; quite likely not more than two weeks.
BUCHHOLZ'S WEAKNESS.
----------
CONFIDING IN ANOTHER PRISONER
----------
Who "Gives Him Way" on the Witness Stand – "If it Hadn't Been for the Detective They Would Never Know I Did It" – A Remarkable Scene in the Bridgeport Court Room – A Witness Who Fights the Court and Lawyers for the Honor of His Family.
BRIDGEPORT, Feb. 20. – At the last trial of William Buchholz for the murder of John H. Schulte of South Norwalk, the testimony of the Pinkerton detective, Stark or Somers, was the feature of the case. He was locked up in the Bridgeport jail with Buchholz, gained his confidence and obtained disclosures which resulted in finding the money of the dead German. It was upon this testimony mainly that a conviction of murder in the first degree was secured and it was generally thought that had Buchholz not been so foolish he would not have been found guilty of at least anything worse than manslaughter. In opposition to the careful instructions of his lawyers were these disclosures of Buchholz made, and he had himself only to blame for the result. After the verdict in the case had been declared invalid by reason of the statements made by a member of the jury during the trial, these instructions to Buchholz were renewed by General Smith and Mr. Bollman, but the foolish Buchholz again disregarded them, and the result was the appearance on the witness stand to-day of a fellow-prisoner who testified to disclosures made by the alleged murderer which almost amount to confession. They were made subsequent to the first trial and when taken in connection with the story of the detective who is yet to testify constitutes a case against him which all the resources and ingenuity of the lawyers for the defense will be needed to break down. Buchholz has for the second time placed the noose about his neck by his unruly tongue.
The testimony of Wells, alias Hineman, the alleged forger, given below, will be found of striking interest. The scene which followed his direct testimony, where counsel for the defense sought to draw from him his antecedents and career, was one of the most remarkable ever witnessed in a court room.
CONCLUSION OF YESTERDAY'S TESTIMONY.
Yesterday's report of the Buchholz case closed with the testimony of Frank Just, the waiter at the Sonne hotel, who carried Schulte to the depot. He was followed by Otto Schwelsky, an employee of the Sonne house, who said he was present when Mr. Schulte left and paid his bill. Mr. Buchholz was sitting near the door when he went away. He turned to the witness saying, "I'll try to get along with him," and followed him to the street. Mr. Buchholz had a trunk brought from Germany and marked: "Adelaide via New York." The trunk was still at the hotel. Soon after the murder a Mr. Berger paid thirty-five dollars due for Mr. Buchholz's board. The witness received from him two twenty-dollar notes and returned five dollars in change. He afterward gave the notes to a man who said he was sent for them by the German consul. The bills were marked with figures in ink.
Mrs. Amelia Waring of Norwalk, whose family lived in the house with Mr. Schulte, near where he was murdered, testified that she first saw him in August, 1877. He bought the farm and boarded with her a week, after which he returned to Germany. He came back on October 2, 1878, with Wm. Buchholz, whom he said he had hired.
"I cooked his meals," said Mrs. Waring, "He usually ate supper between four and half-past, and we saw very little of him after that. He retired to his room about six. He never left the house after sundown. When he went out William generally accompanied him. Mr. Schulte always went ahead, and William followed him. On their return William had the lead. They seemed to get along together without much trouble. One day, however, I heard loud talking between them about the contract up stairs. William came down with the document in his hand. I asked him what was the matter. He said that under the contract Mr. Schulte claimed that he had a right to kick him, and he replied that if he kicked him he would not stay a moment longer. William visited New York once or twice before the matter. One day after that Mr. Schulte asked him whether William had told me that he was to leave him on the 20th of January. He stood on the stairs and William was near by. William replied, "Yes, Mr. Schulte; that's all right."
"On Friday morning, December 27, 1878," Mrs. Waring continued, "I sent Mr. Schulte's breakfast up stairs, and he ate it. On coming down he gave me the key to his room. This was contrary to his custom. He usually hung the key on a nail in the sink room. William had preceded him down stairs, and had gone through the kitchen up to his own room. Mr. Schulte had told me before this that he was going to New York. I may have told William, but I am not positive. I asked Mr. Schulte when he would be back. He replied, 'At four o'clock or in the evening.' Meantime William had again come down stairs. He did not accompany him to the depot. As Mr. Schulte walked off I heard him talking to William, who must have been standing in the door. William stayed home the most of the day, reading. He went to the Five Mile Run and back with me. He left the house in the afternoon between three and four o'clock. My daughter was going skating. She asked him to go with her. He said: ‘I thank you, lady, but I must go to meet Mr. Schulte.' I spoke about going with him, but changed my mind and said that I would lie down. He replied, 'Oh, come on. It will do you good.' He went off through the woods toward the railroad, the way he usually went to the depot. I heard the up train go through at 6:30. After that I heard the down train running into the depot. The schedule time is 7:45 [it must be 6:45]. A few minutes afterward I heard my daughter shout to her brother: ‘Sammy, Sammy, William is calling you.' I opened the door, and William fell in on the floor. He had a satchel in his hand. He lay on the floor some moments. Sammy asked him two or three times, 'Where is Mr. Schulte? What's the matter?' He finally gasped, 'He is being murdered, or he is dead in the woods – tramps!' He began to weep. He said he would get his pistol and shoot them. Sammy said he would get Mr. Schulte's gun and kill them. William replied, 'I go with you. I no afraid.' He was then sitting on a chair. He went to a cigar box and got his pistol, and then fell on the floor in a fainting condition. I got some water and wet a towel to bathe his head. He partially revived. I asked him whether he felt able to go to the neighbors with us for help. He answered, 'Oh, yes, I go with you, Mrs. Waring.' We went around the house to see whether the coast was clear, and then went to the house of the nearest neighbor, Mr. Allen. As I entered the house I looked at the clock. It was twelve minutes after seven. I told Mr. Allen what had happened, and said I had come to get some help. He asked where the young man was, and I said out doors. When I went out William stood near the stoop with his hand to his face. Afterward he came in with Sammy, and sat down. He seemed to be dazed. I gave him Mrs. Allen's camphor bottle, and after a spell the three went out together."
"I next saw them at our house at 10 o'clock, when Mr. Schulte's body was brought up. William was silent. I said: 'Will you go to bed?' He replied: I can no sleep.' I told him to go up stairs with Sammy and sleep on the floor in my room. He thanked me and went. In the night I got up to put some coal on the fire, and saw that he was awake. I asked him the matter, and he answered; 'I can no sleep.' In the morning he arose a little after 6 o'clock. He went to Norwalk about 8. Mr. Berger, the constable, afterward took a pair of pantaloons from his room."
Mrs. Warring identified the pantaloons, but failed to identify a shirt and an axe that were shown her. On cross examination Gen. Smith tried to elicit a conversation showing that the arrangement between Messrs. Schulte and Bucholz under which they were to separate on Jan. 20 had been rescinded, but the court ruled the question out because it did not come within the rule of evidence. Gen. Smith took an exception. The court then adjourned.
To-Day's Testimony.
Mrs. Waring resumed the witness stand to-day and was further cross-examined. She said she was greatly excited on the evening of the December 27; nothing had ever effected her so except the explosion of the boiler of the steamer Adelphi. Buchholz appeared frightened and out of breath. There was blood upon him but whether it was dry or dripping she could not say.
Victor Robe of Brooklyn, testified that he became acquainted with Buchholz in New York in August, 1878. He came over from Germany with his brother. After Buchholz went to live with Schulte in Norwalk, Buchholz came to see the witness and tried to borrow money of him. He told of having had trouble with Schulte and of drawing a pistol upon him.
STARTLING TESTIMONY.
A good-looking young man then took the stand, who answered to the name of R. S. Hineman.
"Where did you come from asked State Attorney Olmstead.
"From the Bridgeport jail," responded the witness.
State Attorney Olmstead – You can answer this question or not. What are you charged with?
Witness – I'm there on a charge of forgery. Last November I was brought here from Utica, N. Y., on a requisition by Chief Marsh.
"Were you confined near Buchholz?"
"In the next cell."
"Now if he has made any communication to you concerning this case, go on and state what they were."
"He talked to me about the case several times. At first he thought I was a detective."
General Smith – No matter what you thought; tell us what was said.
Witness – Well, I heard him tell a hall man that he believed I was a detective. He thought the man Nobles was a detective too. I said I wished I was one, then I wouldn't be in jail on a charge of forgery. It was a standing joke; they all called me detective. I guess I'm dubbed that now. I told Buchholz I wasn't any detective, and sent him copies of the Farmer containing something about my case and other matters. When I had potatoes, I took them in his cell and cooked them, and we ate them together. We cooked steaks together and other things. Every Friday we had codfish balls. I told him if I could only get out of the jail I thought I could get him out. He said I would never regret it if I did. I said I thought I could get some saw and cut the cell bars; I knew ladies who would bring them to me. He said he'd fix me if I would only get him out; that he'd take me to Germany and Paris and all around and we'd be gentlemen and have a good time. I said it would require a good deal of money to do all this. He said that would be all right. I told him I had lady friends who would do a great deal to help me out and that I knew of places in New York where a man could hide for a month or so and keep out of the way. Buchholz spoke about a young lady, he said she was in the country somewhere and spoke as if he was engaged to her. He said she didn't know anything about the case; she didn't see the papers. I told him if I could got out I would send back to the jail and try and get him out with saws. By and by there were some painters who came to the jail and worked painting the jail; told the painters -
What he told the painters was ruled out.
Witness continued: "Well, I planned to walk out with the painters when they got through work at night. I tried to get overalls from the men. When the man who was to give the overalls failed me I tore a sheet in the shape of pantaloons, and they were sewed in Buchholz cell. Buchholz sewed them. I watched at the door of the cell to see that no one was coming while he did it. I expected that if I got out I would get him out. He said if I could he would do something that would open my eyes. Of course this gave me the impression that he had some money somewhere."
"No matter about your impression," said Gen. Smith.
Witness continued – "The sheet racket was given away to Jailor Wells. He came to my cell and found the sheet and said those look like pants. When I knew the racket was given away I tore them up. I had darkened them over with paint so that they looked like overalls. I talked with Buchholz about his getting bail, but he said his lawyers wouldn't let him get the money. I asked him how much he would give to get out, and he said $6,000 cash. There were a number of us who heard him say that. Then I made arrangements with a man to bring me some saws. I thought he would. He said he would. I wrote a letter about it to Burns, who was released from the jail.
BUCHHOLZ'S DISCLOSURES.
One day we were talking about this case and Buchholz said Somers, the detective, wasn't very smart, or he would have found more money. I thought he was going to tell me where the money was, but he didn't. I intended to get him out if I could."
State Attorney Olmstead – "What's that. Then you really intended to get him out if you could?"
The Witness – "Certainly I did, all the time. We talked about what we would do if we could escape. I asked him where the money was. He said he wouldn't tell me. That if I knew I might get it. The interest would be all on my own side. If he didn't tell me I would have more interest in getting him out. If I did so it would be all right; he would fix me. He said Somer's evidence was all there was against him and that it would be a good idea to get him out of the way. He said he didn't want to kill him but to keep him closed up. I said Pinkerton's agency was in Philadelphia, but he said he knew of ladies who had seen Somers on the streets in New York, that he could be found there. The plan was to get him out of the way, get him locked up and get him to write a letter. Buchholz said I was a good penman and could imitate his writing and could write a letter to State Attorney Olmstead and another to Buchholz's lawyer, saying that he (Somers) didn't want to testify against an innocent man. We were to mail the letter from Canada or California."
State Attorney Olmstead – "Did you make any memorandum of what Buchholz said to you at the time."
The Witness – "Yes. I have two with me."
The witness read them. They were to this effect:
"If it hadn't been for the son of a — of a detective they would never have known I did it, and they would [not] have got the money. I would have been a free man if I had had time to get away.
"If the detective had been smart he would have got more money."
The witness said that he took down the memorandums from one to three hours after Buchholz made the statements. He did it so as to have something to bind Buchholz so that he couldn't go back on him.
The witness said that there was some talk about disguises for Buchholz in case he got out. He suggested that he get false teeth and wear high heeled boots. Buchholz said he could dye his hair, but Hineman replied that it wouldn't do for his complexion was too light. The difference would be too light. Buchholz said that in Germany they had a way of altering the color of the eyes and asked the witness to ask Dr. Phillipi, another prisoner in the jail, about it.
Yesterday's Third Edition
Bucholz's Weakness.
The witness continued – One day Jailor Wells took the pipes away from the prisoners. He took Buchholz's but overlooked mine and Hoyt's. I had been talking and laughing with Buchholz and started for his cell to loan him the use of my pipe. Dr. Phillipi had told me he (Buchholz) felt bad about losing his. Buchholz wouldn't let me in. He would not reply to me when I asked what was the matter.
State Attorney Olmstead – "When did you first speak of your conversation with Buchholz?"
Witness – "I told Detective Frank Taylor. I consulted with my counsel as to whether he was to be trusted. I told him about the matter confidentially. I spoke because I wanted him to go and get the money. I wanted to get bail and get out. He promised me he wouldn't say anything about the matter.
A REMARKABLE CROSS-EXAMINATION.
The first question asked the witness by General Smith, was: "Where were you born."
Witness – "I don't want to state that. There is a case against me here. I don't want my people at home to know about it."
State Attorney Olmstead said he felt it his duty to protect the witness as far as he could. He quoted the Norwalk tramp case, where a man was allowed by the court to keep back his antecedents on account of his family.
The court ruled he must answer.
The Witness – "I was born in the state of Kentucky."
"What is your name?"
The Witness – "I don't want to answer. I didn't proffer my testimony in this case. I didn't want to come here. It may injure my case if I answer."
General Smith – "What is your name?"
Witness – "I decline to answer."
Gen. Smith – "You'll have to tell."
Chief Justice Park – "We think witness should answer the question."
The witness – "Suppose I refuse. What are you going to do then."
The court – "The witness had better answer."
The witness became very much excited, drank frequently from a tumbler of water and snapped his finger in a nervous way. "Then I suppose I must. Everything I say goes against me in my case. (Turning to the court.) Then you say I must tell."
Chief Justice Park – "You had better answer.”
The Witness – "My name is John W. Wills."
General Smith – "Where are you known?"
The Witness – "'Most everywhere. In New York, Chicago, St. Louis, Louisville, California, –
General Smith – "That will do. Who knows you in New York as John W. Wills?"
Witness – "I decline to state."
General Smith – "Who are the respectable people in New York who know you."
The witness – The police and detectives don't know me.
After hesitating some little time the witness said he was "trying to think of the people he cared the least about."
General Smith – "Give us the names of some of those who care about you."
State Attorney Olmstead said he had sent for the prisoner's counsel. He thought he had a right to know what his rights were in this court and what would be the consequence if he did not answer. The witness' counsel, W. C. Wildman, soon after arrived and Hineman was about to leave the witness stand and consult with him when General Smith objected to his holding any communication with anyone while testifying.
Mr. Wildman addressed the court and said he desired to instruct the witness and tell him what his rights were, how far he must go, and what the penalty would be if he refused to answer.
General Smith objected to Mr. Wildman's saying anything, and said he had no status in the court for the purposes of this case.
Chief Justice Park said he thought the witness should go on. The court must be the judge as to whether anything he was asked would criminate him if he answered.
The witness said the parties he knew in New York were not residents there. They could not be called New Yorkers. There was one a medical student who had since gone away who lived where the witness did, and he didn't want to mention his name because he didn't want the people there to know about the case.
General Smith – "Who is this medical student?"
The Court – "The witness had better answer."
The Witness – "Walter Burns"
General Smith – " Who else in New York?"
The Witness – "I don't think of any one else."
The witness said he was known in Philadelphia as Wills by Rev. Mr. Wiley's son. He wouldn't tell where he lived; but said he was a prominent man. Also by a young man named Harry Hart, who belongs to a first class family, a gentleman by birth, and "all that sort of thing."
Gen. Smith – "What business is he in?"
The witness – "Not any."
The witness said the chief justice of the supreme court of Missouri knew him and his family. He lived near where witness formerly did, on Locust Place, St. Louis. His father's name is John Wills. "He was at one time United States sub-treasurer I believe," said the witness, but Gen. Smith interrupted to say he hadn't asked about that.
The witness said he had held no communication with his family for a year or more. He had been in New York and Philadelphia.
"What did you do while in New York?"
"Well, a friend of mine and myself used to buy stocks."
General Smith – "Who was this friend?"
"Frank Camp."
General Smith – "What is his address?"
The Witness – "That is what I should like to know? He lived while in New York at 12 Gramercy Place, at a large boarding house near the residence of Samuel J. Tilden."
Gen. Smith – "What is your sister's name?"
The Witness – "No. She is highly respectable. Her husband's law partner is a member of congress. I have respect for the court and all that sort of thing but I have more for my sister, and I don't want to drag her into this criminal case."
The witness positively refused to answer notwithstanding the instructions of the court.
Gen. Smith said the whole story was in his judgment a fabrication. He demanded the name but finally withdrew the question temporarily.
Chief Justice Park ruled that the witness need not answer the question until he had had an opportunity of consulting with his counsel during recess.
The counsel for the defense objected to such a consultation, but the chief justice replied that that was a matter which lay in the discretion of the court.
Second Edition
THE BUCHHOLZ CASE.
----------
Cross-Examination of Heineman Completed – Jailor Wells' Testimony.
BRIDGEPORT, Feb. 21. – The cross-examination of John W. Wills alias R. S. Heineman, in the Buchholz case, was completed yesterday afternoon, the testimony of Jailor Wakeman Wells was taken, and the court adjourned until 10 a. m. Tuesday. The question as to the name of witness' sister was renewed without eliciting the desired information. Pending the decision of the court the past record of Wills was made the subject of a lengthy cross examination. He admitted a series of forgeries, amounting to $5,400, on the Philadelphia National bank five or six years ago, for which he served three years in prison and then was pardoned. He afterwards visited Baltimore, New York, Chicago and Louisville; was arrested in Utica and brought from that place here. Although mentioning the names of parties highly connected in those places as persons knowing his name, history and family connections, he studiously avoided reference to any person familiar with his record since he left prison, two years ago, and was finally sustained in his refusal to disclose the name of his sister by the ruling of the court, to which the defense excepted. Witness offered to give the name in private to counsel, provided it was not disclosed in court or given to the reporters. General Smith refused to accept the terms proposed.
The witness said he was sentenced to five years in the Philadelphia prison for the forgeries, and pardoned out in 1877; next went to New York city, and staid at Earle's Hotel; had $300 or $400 furnished him by his relatives when he came out of prison, and since then had bought stocks and made some money legitimately.
"How old are you?" inquired Gen. Smith.
"There you go with your dates again!" said the witness. "I may be 24 or 25 or 26; can't say which."
In reply to further questions, he said his birthday was May 30, but the year of his birth he couldn't tell. He finally concluded that his age was 25.
Wakeman Wells was called. Asked if he knew about a pair of overalls found in Heineman's cell. Objection was raised and the question was dropped. Witness said that Buchholz's and Heineman's cells were side by side; they were often together in the corridor when out for a respite; thought they could talk to each other from the doors of their cells; did not think they were ever together in their cells unless it was at the time they were let out as above said in the corridor. The doors of the cells were left open for an hour.
The evidence of this witness was intended mainly to be corroborative of what Heineman had said regarding his conversation with Buchholz, and as to what connections he had while in jail with the accused.
The judge, prior to the departure of the jury, charged them at some length on their conversing about the case. He warned them to be guarded at all times.
The second trial of the Buchholz case at Bridgeport promises to be, if possible, more interesting than the former trial. New and dramatic evidence has already been introduced by the state in the shape of another confession by the prisoner to a detective who did not appear at the preceding trial. The prisoner seems to have the "gift of gab" dangerously well developed, and if he does not swing for his lingual looseness he will be unusually lucky. Whether the Bridgeport women mean to adorn the accused murderer with button-hole bouquets and otherwise make fools of themselves generally, as in the former trial, remains to be seen. It is to be hoped that they will not do such nonsense.
THE BUCHHOLZ TRIAL.
----------
A DRAMATIC SCENE IN COURT.
----------
One of Buchholz's Fellow Prisoner Utterly Refuses to Testify Against Him Because "He was Kind to Me" and is Committed by the Court for Contempt Until he Answers.
BRIDGEPORT, Feb. 24. – The Buchholz trials have not thus far lacked in persecution but in many respects the scenes just after the opening of the court this morning was the most exciting and dramatic. A prisoner at the Bridgeport jail was called upon to testify against his fellow prisoner Buchholz. He was supposed to have been another confidant of the foolish German on trial for his life. He was apparently a simple-minded sort of a fellow, but had too high a sense of honor to "give away" the man who had been kind to him in jail and was now fighting to escape the gallows. He utterly refused to tell what Buchholz had told him, and neither State's Attorney Olmsted or Chief-Justice Park could draw anything out of him, although he was informed he would be punished for his refusal. So the court committed him for contempt until he changes his mind.
The witness expressed the fear that he would criminate himself if he testified, notwithstanding that both Mr. Olmsted and the court informed him that he would not be asked anything about his own case. But the terrible ordeal which Heineman, alias Wills, passed on the cross-examination may have been before his eyes and had much to do with his refusal to answer. However this may be, he placed his declination upon the ground of his reluctance to "give away" one who had been kind to him and talked to him in confidence.
Buchholz watched the witness from the dock, and his face lighted up perceptibly when he refused, point blank, to testify.
It was half past ten o'clock when the Buchholz case was resumed before Chief Justice Park and Judge Loomis to-day. The first witness called was George H. Graff. When asked what his name was he said, "George Groff." "Any middle name," was asked. The witness hesitated a long time. The question was put in a different way, "Is your middle initial 'H.’” "Yes," said the witness, after a long wait.
State Attorney Olmstead – "Where are you now living.”
The Witness – "In the Bridgeport jail. I've been there four months."
"Do you know William Buchholz?"
The Witness – "I got acquainted with him in the jail."
"Has talked with you about the case now on trial?"
"I have conscientious scruples against testifying against a man. I ain't going to say nothing about it no one."
Mr. Olmstead – "You must answer the question.”
The witness utterly refused to answer. "He (Buchholz) always treated me like a man," he said, "and I am [not] going to answer. I decline to answer."
Chief Justice Park – "The witness must answer." (To the witness) – "If you don't answer we will have to punish you."
Mr. Olmstead – "Did you say anything to Buchholz about murdering the old man?"
The Witness – I ain't going to say nothing."
Mr. Olmstead – "If the court pleases we deem this evidence of great importance and insist upon an answer. (To the witness) – You have heard the court say you must answer. Do you know Heineman?"
The Witness – "I got acquainted with him at the jail."
Mr. Olmstead – "Did you talk with him about the murder of the old man?"
The Witness – "It will criminate me to answer."
The Court – "You are asked nothing about your case and must answer. Do you still decline to answer, understanding that you will be punished if you still refuse."
The witness placed his hand over his heart and said, "Whatever has been said to me will remain here."
Chief Justice Park – "The court commits the witness for contempt of court to jail until he answers the question, or until further orders of this court."
Mrs. Sadie Waring, daughter of Mrs. Amelia Waring, in whose house in South Norwalk John H. Schulte, the murdered German, resided, was the next witness. She said Buchholz came to Schulte in the capacity of a servant. The morning of the day of the murder she saw Buchholz fire off a revolver into the air. She described the scenes of the murder in confirmation of her mother. She heard Buchholz soon after he left the house in the evening calling out from the woods "Sammy, Sammy." When he reached the house he had a satchel in his hand and fell fainting on the floor. He sat down on a chair and then fell off. He said, "I can't stay here and Mr. Schulte down in the woods;" also something about "no fraid to go down in the woods" and "dead, dead, down dere in the woods." The witness said she never knew Schulte to go out after dark except once when he came from the boat.
On the cross-examination the witness said she was not positive that the pistol shown in court was the one Buchholz had on the morning of the murder. She said Buchholz was a quiet, peaceable sort of a man, and that he and Schulte got along without quarrels or jars. The day of the murder Buchholz passed his time as usual, and appeared in every way as usual. The witness said she heard the 6:48 train, and five minutes later she heard the screams of Buchholz in the woods. She thought Buchholz, after he came into the house, said something about Schulte's being attacked. He said "dead, dead," and something like "attacked," but what, the witness could not tell.
Miss Annie Waring, a sister of the preceding witness testified in corroboration. The facts in relation to what occurred on the night of the murder were gone over again without bringing to light anything of importance. The night of the murder Samuel and Sadie Waring ran to neighbor Allen's house for help. Subsequently, at the request of the states attorney, the space was gone over to ascertain the length of time taken by them. Everything of importance that was done on the night of the murder was gone over for the benefit of the attorney and those who were with him. Gen. Smith, counsel for the prisoner, objected to the admission of testimony relating to what was said at the time that the experiments were made but the court ruled it in and exceptions were taken.
THE TRIAL OF BUCHHOLZ.
----------
TO-DAY'S TRIAL AT BRIDGEPORT.
----------
A Session Devoted Mainly to Lengthy Cross-Examinations – Witnesses with Poor Memories. Why Groff Did Not Testify Against His Fellow-Prisoner – A Confirmation of Heineman's Testimony.
BRIDGEPORT, Feb. 25. – The hearing in the Buchholz case this morning was uninteresting when compared to previous sessions. The testimony of the men who went into the woods and found the dead body of John H. Schulte was taken. Lengthy and rather dreary cross-examinations followed, productive of but little but the fact that the witnesses could not remember every little detail of what occurred on the night when the murder was discovered and that they had testified somewhat differently at the first trial. The contradictions shown were of but little importance except as showing that the memory of the witness was not perfect.
Among those who were present in the court this morning was Robert Pinkerton. He will shortly be called upon to testify that Stark, the detective, is in his employ. Stark or Somers will then tell the story of his life in the Bridgeport jail and how he gained the confidence of Buchholz and wrung from him the disclosure which led to the finding of the money of the dead German.
Graff, the witness who utterly refused to testify against his fellow prisoner yesterday, was not brought down to the court room today. There has been some outside talk about his being punished for contempt of court by being locked up in a dark cell, fed on bread and water and kept from all contact with the other prisoners. It is even reported that State Attorney Olmstead is desirous that this should be done, on the ground that in no other way can Graff be punished, as he is already in jail, awaiting trial for the theft of a boat, and an order from the court that he be kept confined until the trial of Buchholz is over would be no punishment at all. However, there is no probability of its being done at present, unless by special order of the court. When upon the stand Groff appeared like a simple-minded fellow who didn't know much, but it was acting and good acting too. He is well known to the detectives as an accomplished criminal. Heineman knows him well and says he (Groff) knows every thief in this part of the country. It is reported that Gen. Smith and Mr. Bollman, Buchholz's indefatigable counsel, visited the jail last Saturday night and that then and there Groff was fixed. After Heineman had testified Buchholz is supposed to have told his lawyer that he had talked with Groff also, and before Mr. Olmstead thought of it they visited the jail. It is said that Buchholz talked with Groff with even more freedom than with Heineman.
Buchholz pays strict attention to the evidence, and rarely takes his eyes off the witness. He appeared more pale and haggard to-day than usual.
COMPLETION OF YESTERDAY'S REPORT.
At the time the REGISTER's report of the Buchholz case closed yesterday Samuel Waring was upon the witness stand. He testified to the finding of the body of John H. Schulte, the murdered German of South Norwalk. He was lying on the ground with his head thrown back; the pocket of one coat pocket had been turned inside out and was sticking out. There was blood upon the face. There were papers and a book upon the ground. The witness identified a pocket dictionary in the book found upon the ground near the body. In the book is a place in which bills or papers could be carried. This the witness said was the only pocketbook, if pocketbook it could be called, found upon the ground at this time.
Mr. Olmstead – Could any of the men who were looking at the body have gone to it and removed a pocketbook.
General Smith objected.
The witness said he did not remember the location of the men who were about the body. He picked up the dictionary but was told to leave everything just as they were found until a coroner had been notified. Buchholz did not say anything as to how the old man was killed, either while in the woods or on the way back to the Waring house. The witness gave an account of the summoning of the coroner's jury. He thought the body was not touched until the jury came to where it lay. He assisted in carrying the body to the Waring house and got to bed about 12 o'clock, sleeping with Buchholz. The witness slept soundly himself and did not know whether Buchholz slept or not. Both got up at about the same time. An axe was shown the witness and he identified it as belonging to the Warings. He also identified a broken handle as the handle that was in the axe the morning of the murder. When he first saw the axe the morning after the murder it was in the hands of Mr. Holtz [Hoyt?] and one other gentleman. It had been picked up near the scene of the murder.
The first portion of the long cross-examination of the witness which followed, was chiefly devoted to the question of time. The witness was not positive whether the train he heard at the supper table before Buchholz appeared was the 6:25 or the quarter to seven. General Smith read from the stenographic report of the first trial of Buchholz, to show that the witness had testified positively that he heard the quarter to seven, but the witness could not remember how he testified before. A marked discrepancy was shown in his testimony at the two trials, at the first he having testified that he found two books by the side of the body, the dictionary book and the pocket-book, while at the present trial he testified positively that he found but the dictionary book at the first finding of the body.
John W. Wills, alias R. F. Hineman, alias J. S. Hamilton, the Kentucky forger, was recalled. He said that in all their conversations in Bridgeport he had no trouble in understanding what Mr. Buchholz said.
General Smith – Can you speak German? A – No, sir.
General Smith – Have you the indictment against this man, Mr. Olmstead?
The District Attorney – I haven't had the time to look it up.
General Smith – Then we will defer the cross examination until you get it.
Mr. Olmstead – I'll keep the witness here.
General Smith – He'll probably be well kept until we get through with him.
Mr. Wills retired in the custody of an officer. Samuel Waring, brother to Sadie and Annie, was called. He corroborated the testimony of his mother and sisters up to the time they went to neighbor Allen's for help.
John Dingee, a gray-headed gentleman, corroborated Mr. Waring's story as to the discovery of the body. He said he saw Samuel Waring pick up the dead man's hat, dictionary and a little canvas specie bag. He advised him to leave them as he found them, and Samuel did so. The dead man's waistcoat was partly unbuttoned, and his coat and overcoat were thrown open. "No one touched the body but myself," said the aged gentleman. "I put my hand on Schulte's heart and found that he had ceased to breathe." Mr. Buchholz carried the package of hams to the house. On the way up he dropped his handkerchief, and asked Mr. Dingee to pick it up. He did so, and returned it to him. Mr. Buchholz did not offer to explain Mr. Schulte's death. The court then adjourned.
TO-DAY'S HEARING.
The cross examination of John Dingee, one of the men who first found the body, which occurred to-day, elicited nothing of importance or special interest.
Delazon Allen, who lives a few rods from the Waring house, testified that on the night of December 27, 1878, Samuel Waring and William Buchholz came into his yard He asked what was the matter, and they said Mr. Schulte and Buchholz had been attacked down in the woods, and that the former was down there hurt. The witness examined Buchholz's face, and saw two or three scratches; the blood had dried upon his face. The witness did not inquire whether he was wounded elsewhere or not. He groaned and asked for water which was given him; he gave no reason for groaning. The witness, Buchholz and the others went to where the body lay. Buchholz stooped over it and said "My God! My God! he's dead, he's dead!" He did not touch the body. Before the group reached the body Buchholz picked up something – it proved to be a bundle of hams – from the ground. Mr. Allen said everything had better be left as it was found until the coroner had been there, but Buchholz – witness thought it was Buchholz – replied "It's mine and I'm going to have it." Mr. Allen went back to the Waring house. Before the body had been brought there his attention was called to a blood stain on the floor of the kitchen; Mrs. Waring said "that's where Buchholz fell in."
On the long cross-examination that followed the witness testified that when Sam Waring picked up the book and papers about the body he handed them to Buchholz, saying "You had better take care of these." Mr. Allen said, "No, Leave everything as we found them; took them away from Buchholz, and threw the book and papers down again near the body. He noticed at the time that Buchholz had a pistol in his hand.
As in the case with the other witnesses, General Smith read from the testimony at the first trial of the prisoner, and forced Mr. Allen to admit that he could not remember how he testified at the first trial in relation to many minor details. Contradictions were shown, chiefly of importance as showing the poor memory of the witness in relation to the minute details.
Samuel and Thomas Ireland, who are neighbors of the Warings, testified to what took place when the authorities were notified and the coroner summoned. While the men were getting their overcoats, Buchholz stopped for a moment at a certain hickory tree.
Edward Hoyt testified that March 15, 1879, he picked up a gold watch near the hickory tree. Schulte's watch was shown in the court-room and identified as the one he found. It ticked a few moments or seconds when he picked it up. It was in good condition, being untarnished. It snowed soon after the murder (December 27, 1878) and the snow remained on the ground until within a few days of the finding of the watch.
Gustav Hadstrom was with Hoyt and testified in corroboration.
Franklin A. Tolles testified to removing a pair of pants from Buchholz's room in the Waring house, after the murder. There were four or five blood stains upon them; on the left leg near the knee. There were other spots. Another pair of pants and other clothes were also removed. The witness identified Buchholz’s clothing shown in court as that he removed and carried to the Norwalk coroner. There were spots upon both pair of pants. The witness also identified the pepper-box pistol as one found near the body.
WILLS CORROBORATED.
State Attorney Olmstead has received the following letter:
Frank’s
DETECTIVE AND COLLECTION BUREAU,
Principal Office 521 Chestnut Street.
Branch agencies
in all the principal
cities of the U. S.
and Europe.
Philadelphia, Feb 22, 1880.
Detective Taylor:
Dear Sir:
In looking over the New York daily Sun of to-day I find you have a young man named John W. Wills, as a witness in the Buchholz murder trial. I was reading the cross-examination of Wills. I will now state to you that his answers in reference to this city are correct. I had charge of his case in reference to the forgeries on the Philadelphia bank. He boarded as he says on Arch street, above Tenth street, at the time of his forgeries here, for I went there the day after he left for the West. I had his trunk detained at St. Louis, but he never called for it. What he states in reference to Baltimore is correct. It was there he was arrested and brought to Philadelphia and his statements in reference to his family are correct. His father is a man of high standing, but John W. Wills at one time a fine young man, when he entered the store of Ashbridge & Co. fell from the company he kept, fast young men and depraved women. I made inquiries of the antecedents of his family when he was here and they stood very high. You tell John, Mr. Chatham of the bank is dead. I give you this to let you know however bad Jack may be, he is telling the truth in many things that I know of. You ask him if he knows Captain Franks of Philadelphia, who had his case in charge here at the first outset. I remain, most respectfully yours,
WM. D. FRANKS.
The prisoners in the Bridgeport jail are reported as showing much bitterness toward Mr. Heineman. He is confined in his cell during the general hours of liberty in the corridors.
YESTERDAY'S THIRD EDITION.
THE TRIAL OF BUCHHOLZ.
----------
EXPERT TESTIMONY OFFERED.
----------
Dr. J. R. Treadwell, the Blood Stain Expert, Finds Blood upon the Waring Axe and upon Buchholz's Pants – A Remarkable Similarity Shown.
BRIDGEPORT, Feb. 26. – The sensation in the Buchholz case to-day was the appearance upon the witness stand of Dr. J. R. Treadwell, the blood stain expert. He testified that he found human blood and chicken blood on the axe found in Mrs. Waring's yard the day after the murder and with which Buchholz is supposed to have killed John H. Schulte. He also testified that he found human blood corpuscles upon Buchholz's pants. His testimony was highly important and exceedingly interesting. Buchholz listened to him with attention, and during the recess had the photographs of corpuscles shown him by his counsel, Mr. Bollman, who explained to him the technical and scientific terms used.
YESTERDAY'S REPORT COMPLETED.
When the REGISTER report closed yesterday F. A. Tolles was on the witness stand. He testified that he found an axe leaning against a chopping-block in the Waring yard the Sunday after the murder. There was a blood stain on it; also a feather, the quill part of which was bloody.
Officer George N. Arnold testified that he saw the axe, but no feathers. There was blood near the butt, and the handle showed the marks of bloody fingers.
Orlando Bartram testified that he carried the axe and Buchholz's pants, on which were blood stains, to Dr. J. R. Treadwell of Boston, the corpuscle expert in the Hayden and other trials.
George C. Stillson, the foreman of the coroner's jury, gave an account of the visit of the jury to the scene of the murder on the night of December 27, 1878. He described picking up the scattered books and papers. From the right side of the waistcoat was taken a foreign envelope, which was found to contain $20,000 in German money and $939 in greenbacks. This money was first placed in a savings bank, and then handed over to the administrators. The witness also described the ambush constructed in the cedar tree, which, within two weeks after was cut down, by some person unknown. On Saturday afternoon a shingle was found in the stone wall between where the body lay and a hickory tree. It was perforated with bullet holes. There were marks of bullets on the stones, but only one bullet was found. A second revolver was found Saturday afternoon. A box of hob-nails, a bundle of keys, and a hair brush with light hairs sticking to it, were also found. Buchholz has light hair, and has admitted that the brush is his. The witness identified the ragged piece of bloody cloth which the prosecution claims was used to wipe the bloody axe.
On the cross-examination the witness said that a record was made of all the articles taken from the body, but it had mysteriously disappeared.
Mary Downey testified that while at Mrs. Waring's house between the 13th and 20th of October, 1878 she saw Buchholz pay Mrs. Waring $160. He had a large roll of bills left and asked Mrs. Waring to keep it for him, as he was going to a German ball. This is new testimony.
Charles Bosch, a gunsmith, testified that the cartridges found in Mr. Schulte's trunk fitted the revolver found in the woods.
James N. Lane, one of the coroner's jurors, testified that Buchholz helped to carry Schulte's body to the Waring house, but had no opportunity to take anything from his pockets.
To-day's Testimony.
The session opened to-day with a cross-examination of Mr. Lane, which revealed nothing of importance, beyond the fact that he believed no blood dropped from Schulte's body when it was carried into the Waring house. The defense desired to show that the blood which, it is claimed, came from Buchholz when he fell into the house might have come from Schulte.
EXPERT TESTIMONY.
Dr. J. R. Treadwell of Boston was called. He testified that he had made the examination of blood stains a specialty for six years, spending at least nine months out of the year, and four and five hours a day at the work. The work consisted in distinguishing the blood of one animal from another by means of the shape and size of the corpuscles by means of the microscope. His researches had been made by examinations and tests of his own.
Mr. Olmstead – Can the difference between the corpuscles of man's blood and fowls' blood be determined?
Dr. Treadwell – Just as certainly as a desk from a chair or a cabbage from a turnip.
Mr. Olmstead – What are the corpuscles?
Dr. Treadwell – The corpuscles, the red corpuscles, are the means by which we distinguish the different kinds of blood. They are little bodies which we find floating round in the blood. In animals that nurse their young they are round and flat on the sides.
General Smith asked that provision be made that the defense might secure the presence of experts.
Judge Loomis in the absence from the bench of Chief Justice Park said he presumed there would be no difficulty about it, and State Attorney Olmstead said he would object to nothing reasonable.
Dr. Treadwell exhibited a photograph of a human corpuscle and it was handed the jury for examination. He said he had taken the photograph himself.
Gen. Smith objected to the jury's being shown anything of the kind on the ground that Dr. Treadwell was not a photographer. The testimony being admitted by the court Gen. Smith took an exception.
Dr. Treadwell was asked to show a photograph of the blood of a chicken that the difference in the corpuscles might be observed.
Gen. Smith objected. He said it appeared from the evidence that the axe was not examined until nine months after the murder. It had been examined the day after the murder by many people, but what was done with it after that until it was examined almost two years after is not shown. There is nothing to show that some designing person may not have tampered with the axe before the examination. Evidence concerning the condition of the axe the day after the murder is no doubt admissible, but not its condition nine months after. Counsel understood that a man named Wilcox took the axe, but who Wilcox was does not appear.
The testimony was admitted, and the court noted Gen. Smith's exception.
Dr. Treadwell resumed his testimony. On the 11th of February, 1880, the axe was brought to him and he took from it some material, moistened it and placed it upon glass for examination. The material came from different spots on the axe. The first examination was made on the 14th, but did not result in very favorable results. The blood corpuscles were found affected by rust and hence were shriveled up. This the Doctor said was a common experience upon primary examinations. But subsequent tests were productive of striking results. The results of the examinations of the various different quantities of material scraped from the blade of the axe were as follows:
First Spot – (On right side of blade when held in front of the examiner with the edge held downwards, close to edge,) found the round and flat corpuscles of mammalian (human) blood as distinguished from the oval corpuscles of the blood of the fowls. Found nothing else he was sure of. Three separate examinations were made.
Second Spot – (Right side of blade, one and one-half inch from edge,) found both kinds of blood, mammalian and fowl.
The doctor was asked whether he could tell which kind of blood appeared to have gotten on to the blade first, the mammalian or fowl, and said that the fowl blood was more effected by the iron rust than the other and appeared therefore to be nearer the iron. This he found to be true in the case of all the material which he took from the blade.
Third Spot (right side near edge) – Found large amount of mammalian blood. It was badly broken up by rust. At first examination there was no result. But on the 20th found large-sized corpuscles and a small amount of an oily or fatty substance.
Fourth Spot – Some corpuscles found, broken up by rust, certain as to mammalian and there may have been some of the blood of a fowl. One test resulted in finding mammalian blood only.
Fifth Spot – Found some mammalian blood.
Sixth Spot – Found both kinds of blood and some kind of a dark acid or coloring matter similar to what was found upon another article examined. It wasn't blood. In color it was bluish black.
Seventh Spot – Not positive corpuscles so broken up by rust: think there were both kinds.
Eighth Spot – Found mammalian blood and there was probably some fowl blood.
Ninth Spot – found masses of colored matter, mixed with blood; also dark piece of woolen fiber, mixed with blood. There was some blood there, but am unable to say of what kind. Have no doubt in my own mind that these were both kinds, but cannot swear.
Tenth Spot – (left side of blade) positive these were both kinds of blood.
Eleventh Spot – found colored matter separate and mixed with blood. which seemed to be of both kinds.
Twelfth Spot – found mammalian blood; other corpuscles were broken up by action of rust and could not be definitely determined.
Fourteenth Spot – Found dark colored particles mixed and separate with blood; on some there was mammalian. In a second examination found mammalian, but no chicken.
Fifteenth Spot – (near butt end of blade), Applied crystal test to determine whether there was blood in material. Crystal test is used to determine the existence of blood; it does not determine its kind. Acid of vinegar purified is used; the substance to be tested is placed in it and when it dries, if it is blood it crystalizes in a certain way. The substance under examination so crystalized and subsequent tests showed it to be mammalian blood. There was no chicken blood.
Sixteenth Spot – (on the wooden handle). Found no blood; substance was probably spittle.
Seventeenth Spot – (on another handle). Found no blood.
Mr. Olmstead put a number of hypothetical questions to the witness, describing a wound similar to that upon Schulte's head and inquiring whether such a wound might have been made to a man lying down from the effects of another wound by an axe. The witness replied in the affirmative.
The next question was whether blood would be spattered by the blow by the axe if the head was covered with blood from another wound? The doctor thought it would be spattered all round.
Q – Suppose a person was standing near and the blood should spatter on his pants what would be the effect?
A – It would sink deep into the texture.
The witness thought a person wounded by a blow by an ax in the manner described, might walk a mile under some circumstances. He identified a pair of pants (Buchholz's) which were shown him, as a pair from which he removed a quantity of material and tested it. He made eighteen slides, and obtained satisfactory results from sixteen of them. He found mammalian blood, but no chicken blood. The direction of the blood spots upon the pants, was upwards rather than downwards. The blood had sank deep into the texture, showing that it was fresh when it penetrated the cloth; had it been clotted and dry, it would have remained on the outside. This condition of things applied to all the sixteen tests.
The witness was asked whether he thought blood would have flown from a body wounded in the manner already described, after it had lain upon the ground for two or three hours, and replied that he thought not, unless the feet were elevated above the head, so that some of the blood that remained might flow out.
The witness identified another pair of pants, called by Mr. Olmstead the "army pants." He said he found in the materials taken therefrom dark-colored masses, similar to those found mixed with blood on the butt of the axe.
On the rag which the state claims was used to wipe the axe was also found the same dark colored matter; what it is Dr. Treadwell does not know.
A hatchet was shown the witness and he said he had examined it. Mr. Olmstead said he did not ask for the result unless the defence wanted it. Gen. Smith knew all about it. The state did claim it.
Gen. Smith said he did not know all about it.
Mr. Olmstead said he knew it was found in the wood and might have known all about it had he desired.
Gen. Smith pronounced the statement a falsehood.
Mr. Olmstead said he had no reply to make, the hatchet question was dropped and the cross examination of Dr. Treadwell began.
DR. TREADWELL CROSS-EXAMINED.
Gen. Smith – How long have you been in the business?
Dr. Treadwell – I have made it a business to examine blood stains about six years.
Gen. Smith – You have testified in a good many murder cases, have you not?
The witness – I have been a witness in several.
Gen. Smith – What are they?
Dr. Treadwell named over the places where he had testified in murder cases: Vermont, Maine, Plymouth, Mass., Concord and Manchester, N. H., etc.
General Smith – Is that all.
Dr Treadwell – Oh, the Hayden case in New Haven.
General Smith – Oh, you testified in the Hayden case, did you?
Dr. Treadwell – Yes, sir.
General Smith – Now, doctor, these corpuscles are very small, are they not? As small as the head of a pin?
Dr. Treadwell – Yes, a good deal smaller.
General Smith – Can you tell me how many corpuscles there are in a drop of blood one-eighth of an inch in diameter?
Dr. Treadwell – One-eighth of an inch in diameter! No sir, I cannot without computing it. I can tell you how many there are in a cubic inch.
General Smith – Well let us have that.
Dr. Treadwell – About 80 million.
General Smith asked the witness a number of questions requiring more or less computation until the doctor got out of patience and when asked to compute the number of corpuscles in a drop of blood one-eighth of an inch in diameter refused point blank to do it. He said the authorities differed as to the size of the corpuscles.
Gen. Smith asked whether scientific experts did not make frequent mistakes in their examinations of corpuscles; whether he did not know of a case in particular where an expert had mistaken the vegetable growth upon a stone for blood corpuscles?
Dr. Treadwell got rid of answering by claiming that he did not know of his own knowledge. He said that rust changed the shape of corpuscles of blood some times. It might change their shape and might not. If the conditions were precisely the same he supposed the changes would be the same.
Gen. Smith – What changes the corpuscles more than rust?
Dr. Treadwell – Nitric acid.
Gen. Smith – I mean something to which they are commonly exposed.
Dr. Treadwell – You did not specify.
Gen. Smith – Then I will. Does not air effect them; atmospheric air I mean?
Dr. Treadwell – The moisture in the air effects them. It swells them up; alters them from concave to round.
Gen. Smith – Does air effect them?
Dr. Treadwell – No, not after they are once dried.
Gen. Smith – Do you not make claims that the scientific world at large will not recognize.
Dr. Treadwell – Not that I know of; my views in regard to the main points are in accordance with those of the majority.
He was asked whether he knew Dr. Woodward. He said he did; he was a surgeon in the United States army and a member of the National Academy of Sciences.
Gen. Smith read over a long list of societies and asked if Gen. Woodward did not belong to them.
Dr. Treadwell did not know. He knew had published two or three pamphlets upon the subject of microscopy and that he had been engaged in the study of that branch of science since 1875.
Gen. Smith – Don't you know he has been a teacher of microscopy since 1857; that he is one of the oldest teachers in the country?
Dr. Treadwell – Know it only from Woodward's own mouth.
General Smith – Does he not deny your claim to be able to distinguish the blood of one animal from that another?
Dr. Treadwell – He admits that it is possible to distinguish the blood of some animals.
Second Edition
SCHULTE'S MARKED BILLS
----------
TRACED TO WM. BUCHHOLZ'S HANDS
----------
The Money the Prisoner Gave to a South Norwalk Saloon Keeper, with a Request that He Keep Still About it, Produced in Court and Identified – Damaging Testimony for the Prisoner.
BRIDGEPORT, Feb. 27. – At the morning session of the Buchholz case to-day, Paul Hirscher, a South Norwalk saloon keeper, was on the stand. A portion of the money of the late Mr. Schulte was traced by this witness to Buchholz. The day after the murder the latter came to his saloon and gave him $200 in twenty-dollar bills to keep for him until the coroner's inquest should be over, with the request that nothing be said about it. "If any one asks you about it," said Buchholz, "you might tell them I gave them to you some time ago, last October or September." Subsequently, he begged Hirscher not to go back on him, and told him he might keep the money. The bills proved to be marked with the tell-tale figures which John H. Schulte placed upon all his money.
MORE EXPERT TESTIMONY.
The REGISTER's report yesterday closed with the cross-examination of Dr. J. R. Treadwell, the blood stain expert. He was followed by Dr. Leonard J. Sanford of New Haven, who testified that human and fowl blood, examined under favorable circumstances, showed marked differences. Blood to penetrate freely into a woollen material must be fresh. Blood would begin to become a little dense two minutes after it had left the veins.
TRACING SCHULTE'S MONEY.
Paul Hirscher was the next witness. He keeps a saloon in South Norwalk opposite the railroad depot. Buchholz told him of two disputes he had with Schulte. On the first occasion the quarrel was about the sale or ownership of some grain. Schulte drew a pistol and Buchholz said he was obliged to take the weapon away from him to avoid being shot. On another occasion Schulte complained that his coal was disappearing very fast and accused his landlady, Mrs. Waring, of taking it. Buchholz took Mrs. Waring's part and Schulte discharged him. After being discharged Buchholz told the witness that Schulte was a rich man. He said, "He has got lots of money in the bank." On Tuesday before Christmas Day, 1878, Buchholz said that he had given a friend of his some money to put in a bank for him. He found that he could not draw his deposit for thirty days and wanted to go to New York to get some money from his friend, whose name he does not mention. He borrowed from the witness sufficient to pay his fare to the city.
The witness was interrupted by a fainting attack and fell to the floor. He was able to go on this morning and testified as follows:
The evening of the murder Buchholz came into my place and enquired about the time when the trains from New York would arrive. I told him. He wanted to know which side of the depot Mr. Schulte would get off and I told him the New Haven side. He said he was sorry he had not brought his pistol with him as he was afraid of tramps. He said they had annoyed him while he was on his way home. They asked him for tobacco and cigars. There was one, an ugly fellow, that he was especially afraid of. Shortly before the 6:11 train arrived Buchholz left the saloon, and soon after the train came in Schulte entered and called for a bottle of lager. I asked him if he had seen Buchholz, and he said no. I told him that Buchholz had been waiting for him since four o'clock. He said "good. I was detained." I went out and saw Buchholz coming out of the waiting room of the depot. I called him over and he came in and Schulte called for another bottle of lager, and they drank it. Schulte paid and they went away. Schulte had a satchel and a paper bundle. Between nine and ten o'clock that night I heard that Schulte had been killed. The next evening Buchholz came in and said, "Ain't it a terrible thing?" I said I thought it was, and asked him whether he got hurt. He said, "Oh, I got off with a scratch." He asked me to give him the name of the man who had warned him about going home at night on the railroad track, that he might be attacked. I told him Louis Deisenroth. He mentioned me to come behind the screen and while there handed me a roll of bills. He said, "Here's my money, $200, I want you to keep it for me while I go up to the coroner's inquest." He said that if any one should ask me when he gave the bills to me I might say some time ago, last October or September. I said to him "The old man must have given these bills to you last night on the way home." I did not hear any reply. I took the money. There were ten twenty dollar bills. One of them I got changed at the depot. Buchholz owed me and I thought I was entitled to it. I did not notice to see whether it was marked. That night Buchholz and Mr. Berger came into my place. Buchholz got a box of cigars and some other things and paid me with a twenty dollar bill. Mr. Illing was there and took the bill and looked at it. He asked Buchholz where he got it. Buchholz said "Of course I got it from the old man." Mr. Illing pointed out to me a mark upon the bill. There were two numbers upon it separated by a crossmark. I afterwards examined the nine twenty dollar bills I had left of the ten Buchholz gave me that evening. They were all marked in the same way. The first number was the same on all – 380. The bill that Buchholz paid me for cigars, etc., I paid out for rent to Mr. Ely [a twenty dollar bill was shown the witness and identified as the one paid for rent]. Buchholz was in my place every day after that. A day or two after the murder he asked me for $35. He said he wanted to go to New York and pay a bill he owed at the Sonne hotel and get a letter that was waiting for him there. I refused to let him have the money that night, and he came in again the next morning. Then I gave him two twenty dollar bills. [Witness identified two bills which Mr. Olmstead said came from the Sonne hotel, New York, as the ones be gave Buchholz. He also identified eight twenty dollar bills which he said he handed to Mr. Olmstead. They were marked as follows: 380 159; 380 168; 380 156; 380 158; 380 170; 380 180; 380 140; 380 179.]
BUCHHOLZ BEGS.
The second Saturday after the murder Buchholz came in my store looking pale and worried. He said he hoped I wouldn't go back on him and that if I came to testify about the $200 that he gave me I would say he gave it to me some time before the murder. He said I could have the money and give him one-tenth or ten per cent. Another time I asked him what he meant and he said: "You can keep that money, you can use it, and I can let you have the money I received to-day from my sister; I got $200 from my sister to-day." He said he expected to board with me when the coroner's inquest was over. During the other trial of Buchholz I sat next to him one day and said to him: "I understand the authorities have been informed you did not get any money from your sister." He said: “That's all right. I know about it." I asked him what he meant and he said that she didn't send him any.
The witness told of various instances in which Buchholz was in his place between the time of the murder and his arrest. At one time he and Buchholz went to Westport together. Buchholz had on a new ulster coat and asked the witness how he liked it. Buchholz wanted the witness to change a $50 bill and talked about going to Westport by sleigh, but there was too little snow on the ground. He said he wanted to see the country a little. On the way to Westport he said he guessed he would go to Germany. He said that if the witness was only a single man he would take him with him, and said it would take only a few hundred dollars to go. After Schulte's watch had been found the witness went to the jail and told Buchholz about it; that it had been found under a hickory tree where he (Buchholz) had been standing and stooping down. Buchholz said he knew about it; that Schulte's watch was like his own, gold and open-faced, and pulled out his own watch and showed it to the witness.
The witness was cross-examined at length, the defense attempting to show that Schulte and Buchholz remained in Hirscher's saloon until near the time when the quarter before seven train got in from New York. This was to show that some one might have arrived on that train, followed Buchholz and Schulte, and murdered the latter.
Yesterday’s Third Edition
The Schulte Murder.
----------
MR. SCHULTE'S NAME.
On the redirect examination Mr. Olmstead asked the witness how he pronounced the German word J-o-h-a-n-n.
"Jo-hann!" responded the witness.
Mr. Olmstead – And H-e-i-n-r-i-c-h?
The Witness – Hein-rich. But both together I pronounce Johann Hein-rich. That is I make only one syllable of the first name when used with the other.
Henry O. Koenig, a reporter of the New York Staats Zeitung, subsequently testified to another matter and was asked as an expert the translation into English of "Johann Heinrich." He said it was John Henry.
Mr. Olmstead – What was you own name while in Germany?
The witness – Heinrich.
Mr. Olmstead – How do you pronounce J-o-h-a-n-n?
The witness – “Jo-hann," with the accent on the last syllable.
Mr. Olmstead – How both words together.
The Witness – Jo-hann Hein-rich.
[This testimony is designed to forestall the expected claim of the defense that the indictment against Buchholz is defective in that the murdered man is called John Henry Schulte instead of John Heinrich Schulte.]
MORE OF SCHULTE'S MONEY.
Of the eleven twenty dollar bills marked in Schulte's peculiar way placed in evidence this morning, seven were traced from Buchholz to Kirscher and thence to State Attorney Olmstead.
Charles La Croix of South Norwalk was placed upon the stand to trace a $50 bill. This was marked 380 | 151. He said that Buchholz came into his place the Sunday after the murder and had some oysters and cigars. He was accompanied by Messrs. Hirscher and Berger. Buchholz proffered the $50 bill in payment, but La Croix did not want to take it; but Hirscher and Berger nodded to him and winked, as much as to say "It's all right," and so he took it. It was partly traced through a number of hands to Mr. Olmstead.
Dudley B. Ely thought Hirscher's landlord accounted for the $20 paid him for rent.
Edward Berger testified that two of the twenty dollar bills were handed him, he thought, by David Dayton in the presence of Buchholz, but Dayton subsequently denied this; he said Buchholz gave them to Berger. Buchholz asked him to take them to New York and settle up his (Buchholz's) bill at the Sonne hotel, and at the same time get the letter from his sister in Germany. Buchholz was especially anxious to get the letter, he said, because there was money in it. Berger testified that he paid the hotel bill and Stephen Newman testified he saw him do it. The bill were marked 380 | 152 and 380 | 185.
SCHULTE'S WOUND.
Dr. Myron W. Munson, a young physician, was called to describe certain bones which were shown him. He said they were parts of the human skull, and came from the side of the head back of the ear. He said the wound such as Schulte's must have been made by a blunt, dull instrument. The bones, Mr. Olmstead says, came from Schulte's head.
BUCHHOLZ' INCONSISTENCY.
Henry O. Koenig, the German reporter, testified that he had a conversation with Buchholz, in which he said that Schulte gave him the $200 he gave to Kirscher just after they left that man's saloon, and shortly before the murder.
Second Edition
BUCHHOLZ'S TRIAL.
----------
Graff, the Mysterious Witness, Tells His Story but it Amounts to Nothing.
BRIDGEPORT, Feb. 26. – When Graff, Buchholz's fellow prisoner, appeared on the witness stand the other day and refused to testify against his friend because he had been kind to him, because he had conscientious scruples about testifying against a man, and because the disclosures which it was supposed Buchholz had made to him were made confidentially – when this man who is under arrest for stealing a boat and claims to be acquainted with all the thieves that make the coast of New England their headquarters – declined to follow the kind advice of Judge Loomis and avoid punishment by telling all he knew, it was thought by many in the court room that he was doing a clever piece of acting. There were a number of men present who are experienced in the handling of criminals, Robert Pinkerton among them. Graff looked and acted like a stupid, simple-minded fellow who could entertain but one idea in his head at the same time; and the idea which he succeeded so well in impressing upon those who heard his testimony was that he would not "go back" on the man whose friendship he had made in the Bridgeport jail; therefore, in order to keep Buchholz from the gallows he would submit to Chief Justice Park's sentence for contempt of court rather than disclose what he knew.
But when Graff told his story yesterday it was easily seen that either he was lying or else he knew nothing that would tend to fasten the murder of John H. Schulte upon Buchholz, and had only before refused to testify for effect.
The witness testified that he was born in Venezuela. He was now a prisoner in the Bridgeport jail with Buchholz. They were often together, and spoke in German so that nobody within hearing could understand what they said. The witness once asked Buchholz if he would like to get out of jail, and the prisoner replied that Graff was a fool to make such an inquiry. Graff then asked him some questions about his own affairs, but Buchholz said his counsel had instructed him not to say anything about himself to his fellow prisoners. The witness said: “If you will help me to get out of jail, I will help you. If I had any money I could get out." Buchholz replied that if Graff had spoken sooner he could have helped him, but he had given all his money to his lawyer. He offered his watch to Graff, and desired him to dispose of it and buy some saws, but the witness refused to take it, saying that he had one of his own. "Well," said Buchholz "it doesn't matter. They couldn't keep me here long if I wanted to get out; but I shall wait for my trial. I shall get off, and then I shall come back and get you out." The witness thanked him, and the prisoner went on to say that when he was out of jail it would be necessary for him to disguise himself by dyeing his hair and getting a set of false teeth. Soon after the Hayden trial the witness, Buchholz, and two or three other prisoners were sitting together talking, generally, about murder cases. They had been speaking in English, but Graff turned to Buchholz and said, in German: "Buchholz, couldn't you have got the money without killing the old man?" "Oh, they can't convict me of that," replied Buchholz. "They would never have suspected me if I had not paid so much of the money to my creditors." Buchholz, the witness said, did not warn him of the probable results of repeating what he had said to him. "But," said Graff. "his looks spoke more than words." Once the witness asked Buchholz why he did not quit the country when he had the money, and the prisoner replied: "Why didn't you mention that before? Good advice always comes too late." He afterward told the witness that had he not been arrested he would have gone to Australia.
Sheriff Adam Sanford testified to the finding of the axe. It was leaning against a block in a barn attached to Mrs. Waring's house, where Buchholz and Schulte had lived. The block and the axe were both stained with blood and the latter was covered with chicken feathers. which led the sheriff to suppose that Mrs. Waring's son had been killing fowls with the axe. Other witnesses were examined to prove that the axe had not been tampered with since it was taken from the barn.
David Dayton was again called to the stand and he testified that when the body of Schulte was found it had on two coats, both open, and with one pocket turned out. A paper parcel was found in another pocket, and, on being opened, it was found to contain money, German and American, to the amount of nearly $20,000. It was given to the foreman of the coroner's jury. The witness identified two coats shown to him as the garments that he saw on Schulte's body. The inner coat, an old black frock, was stained with blood. The witness said it had been taken off, rolled up, and placed under the dead man's head. The wounds were bleeding slightly, and the blood rolled upon the coat. The witness described the bringing home of the body.
H. W. Lyon, general agent of the Northwestern Mutual Life insurance company, has submitted an offer to General W. R. Smith of Norwalk to insure the life of the alleged murderer, William Buchholz, for $1,000 for one year, the policy to be made payable to Messrs. Smith and Bollman, his counsel, Mr. Lyon himself contributing one-fourth of the premium. The proposition will probably be accepted.
THE TRIAL OF BUCHHOLZ.
----------
MORE "JAIL BIRD" TESTIMONY.
----------
A Witness who the Defense Claim is Prejudiced – Buchholz's Testimony Before the Coroner’s Jury Brought Up Against Him.
BRIDGEPORT, March 2. – In the Buchholz case to-day another "jail bird," as the counsel of the defense style this class of witnesses, testified against his companion in the Bridgeport jail. He had but little to say, however, of point, the most that can be made out of it being a corroboration of that portion of Heineman's testimony in which he tells how Buchholz and he tried to construct a pair of overalls out of a sheet which they hoped was to enable one of them to escape with some painters who were then at work in the jail, after which the other was to gain the release of the other by means of saws which were to sever bolts and bars. Not the least interesting portion of to-day's testimony was the reading of the testimony of Buchholz before the coroner's jury held shortly after the murder of Schulte.
A large portion of the morning session was consumed by swabbles between the lawyers. At one time during the cross-examination of Mr. Ayers, Mr. Bollman accused State Attorney Olmstead of indicating how he wanted the witness to answer by shaking his head at times. This Mr. Olmstead indignantly denied.
YESTERDAY'S TESTIMONY.
Yesterday Dr. M. D. Parder [Pardee] identified several pieces of bone he had taken from Schulte's skull at the post mortem examination, showing the jury their position in an uninjured cranium, and testified that Buchholz's face was only slightly scratched the night of the murder.
Several expert jewelers opined that Schulte's watch would not be injured by lying under the snow three months.
Benjamin M. Ayers of South Norwalk testified that he had walked over the route taken by Buchholz and Schulte in 19 ½ minutes from the station to where the body was found, and that he had run thence to the Waring house in 1 minute, 18 seconds, the whole time being 20 minutes, 18 seconds, which included stopping long enough to commit the deed and going to the barn near the house. This testimony is intended to support the theory of the state, that Buchholz had time enough to murder Schulte, hide his booty in the barn and appear when he did at the house.
A POINT FOR THE DEFENSE.
The cross examination of Ayers was continued this morning and much time was spent upon the hatchet head which he found in the woods on the last day of the former trial of Buchholz He got a boy to climb a tree near the scene of the murder, and the hatchet fell from its limbs while the boy was up in it. The hatchet has already been exhibited in court. Dr. Treadwell, the bloodstain expert, testified that he examined it, but was not allowed to say whether he found any blood corpuscles upon it. Ayers testified, however, that he found what he thought to be blood and one or two gray upon it. A copy of the South Norwalk Sentinel of October 8, 1879, was introduced by the lawyers for the defense; it contained an advertisement, or rather an editorial upon the Buchholz case headed "That Hatchet." Ayers testified that he was instrumental in securing the insertion of the article. Some time after finding the hatchet he called upon Gen. Smith, wishing to place the testimony in the hands of those interested in the case. Smith said to him that the testimony might be very important no matter whether it was true or fabricated evidence, and that it might be of some use to him. The witness did not remember that he said he wanted money for the testimony. He did not give up the hatchet or show it to the General, and would not swear that he did not refuse to give it up unless he was paid for so doing. The witness finally concluded to hand the hatchet to Mr. Olmstead.
On the re-direct examination the witness said he should not have gone to General Smith except that his counsel Mr. Blake, advised him to.
The counsel for the defense claimed in the course of the numerous squabbles and brief arguments, that the witness was biased and that his evidence was fabricated.
A STENOGRAPHER TESTIFIES.
Frank G. Fowler, the official stenographer of the court, was called to the witness stand. He leaned over and spoke to Chief Justice Park in a low tone.
"We can't hear you," said State Attorney Olmstead.
The witness explained that he was saying that he was engaged in reporting both sides of the case, was willing to do what was fair in the matter –
Mr. Olmstead – Interrupting, I submit –
Chief Justice Park – Go on with the inquiries.
Mr. Olmstead – Were you in Norwalk at the time there were made some walking experiments?
The Witness – Yes.
Mr. Olmsted – Did I ask you to go or did you ask to go with me?
The Witness – You said you were going to the grounds, and as I wanted simply to look over the grounds I asked you if you had company there, implying, I suppose, that I would like to go.
Gen. Smith objected to the testimony on the ground that as the witness was the official stenographer of the court and might be influenced in some way the cross-examination.
Chief Justice Park said the question was a legal one and the testimony must come in.
The witness said he walked from the South Norwalk depot to the ant hill (where the murder occurred) at the rate of 124 steps per minute; he should call at a brisk gait. From the depot to the point where he left the railroad tracks and climbed the fence 18 ½ minutes were consumed; from the fence to the cedar tree one minute. He slackened his pace a little for a few seconds to make his memorandum. From the cedar tree to the ant hill was one-half minute. The total was twenty minutes. It took one minute and sixteen seconds to go from the ant hill to the Waring house.
The witness described the tracks that were made in the Waring house, where the scenes the night of the murder were repeated by the family. The first trial occupied from two to three minutes; the second three minutes and forty seconds. One of the Waring girls ran to the Allen house in 53 seconds. The distance was about 70 feet [this must mean 700 feet, but in any case it's probably more than 1000].
Mary Downey, who at the time of the murder lived near the railroad track, between the South Norwalk depot and the point from which the path to the Waring House branches off, and worked in a manufactory near Upper Norwalk, testified that the night of the murder she walked home, going by the tracks. The 6:30 p. m. train passed her on the way. In front of her house she met William Richards and talked with him five or six minutes. While standing there she saw William Buchholz and Schulte pass along. Buchholz was a short distance ahead. She had seen them before out walking and thought they were good walkers. It was twenty minutes before seven when she got into the house. As she sat down to supper she heard the quarter before seven o'clock.
A PRISONER ON THE STAND.
Edward Brown, colored, a prisoner at the Bridgeport jail, took the stand. Buchholz appeared flushed and nervous. He said he saw Heineman and Buchholz in the former's cell sometime last November working upon a sheet which had been cut into the shape of a pair of pants. Buchholz was doing the sewing. Painters were at that time at work in the jail. Heineman had previously endeavored to borrow a pair of pants from the witness.
THE SNOW.
Mr. Stillson, the foreman of the coroner's jury, was recalled. He said it snowed the Saturday after the murder. The snow melted gradually at times, and disappeared in a rain storm three months later. Then it was that Schulte's watch was found.
DR. PARDEE.
Dr. Pardee, who made the post mortem examination of the body of Schulte, testified that in his opinion the scratches upon Buchholz face were not serious enough to have saturated the day after they were inflicted.
On the cross-examination he tried to explain how it was that at the coroner's jury he testified that the wound on the side of Schulte's head was three inches deep while at the present trial he said it was only two.
THE DETECTIVE'S STORY.
----------
TESTIFYING AGAINST BUCHHOLZ.
----------
Stark's Stay in the Bridgeport Jail – A Portion Only of Buchholz's Disclosures Told – Arguing Over the Admission of Testimony.
BRIDGEPORT, March 3. – Stark, alias Somers, the Pinkerton detective, began his story of his life in the Bridgeport jail and his intimacy with Buchholz there and its results, at the opening of the court this morning. Before he had reached the important disclosures which Buchholz made to him and which resulted in the finding of Schulte's money, he was interrupted by other witnesses, whom, from one reason and another, were anxious to get away at once. Most of the morning was spent in preparing the way for the admission of statements made by Buchholz before the coroner's jury, the defense objecting to their admission because Buchholz was then under custody.
YESTERDAY'S TESTIMONY.
After the close of the REGISTER's report yesterday, Paul Schmaeck testified that he found seven gold pieces and an old pocketbook containing 204 one-thousand mark notes, and a passport made out in Schulte's name, under a wood-pile near the Waring house. Mr. Olmsted put in evidence $4,787 in greenbacks, found in the barn by Detective Stark.
Henry Bischoff, a New York banker, testified to the money he delivered to Schulte. He was not sure in his identifications, and when an old-fashioned pocketbook was shown him, he said Schulte's book was like it, but he thought older and with more pockets.
The total amount of the money put in evidence was $53,017; it was all identified by Stark. The testimony was put in, preparatory to his evidence.
STARK'S STORY.
At nine o'clock this morning Stark, or Somers, the detective, took the witness stand and told his story, as follows:
"I was instructed to proceed to Bridgeport and find out the truth of the Schulte matter, and in order to get into the jail I was told to call at the Adams Express office for a package. I did so, and was arrested by Officer Arnold. He took me to the station house, where I was kept from Saturday until Monday. That day I was brought before the police court, waived an examination, was bound over, and in default of $1,500 was sent to jail. At first I was reticent to the other prisoners. One man, hearing I was a German, offered to introduce me to another German, who he said was in the jail, but I refused on the ground that I had enough to do to attend to my own affairs. After having been in jail five or six days I saw Buchholz and became acquainted with him. The next day he asked me if he could cook something on a little stove that I had, and I let him. After that I spoke to him more or less every day, but not about his case until several days after my imprisonment. One day, I think Buchholz was reading the New York Zeitung – the piece was about his case. I asked him how he was connected with the case. He then told me he was Schulte's servant. I asked, 'Did they find any axe?' He replied no; that they found some pistols. I asked him if Schulte was shot and he said no and proceeded to describe three wounds which he said Schulte had, and he further stated that he himself was attacked in the woods. He described the man that struck him. There were two men, he said, who attacked him, but he described one. This one, he said, had a soft black felt hat and had a beard. I told him he ought to be able to identify the men but he said something about its being dark; he said he could only see about so far and indicated something in the jail about fifteen feet from where we were standing. One day I asked him whether he ever said that he had received any money from his sister and he replied that he had never said so to anyone. Another time he again spoke of the murder giving the same narration as the time before, about his being attacked by two men, etc, and I told him that there was a man in the jail named Burns, who had spoken of money being found on Buchholz's person with Schulte's private mark upon it. Buchholz said, "Oh pshaw, what does he know about money; they found no money on me." Sometime afterwards Sheriff Sanford came into the jail with a man who I afterwards learned was the door keeper named Hursche. He went in to see Buchholz. After they left I passed Buchholz's cell. He was eating, and his face was flushed and he seemed troubled, and soon afterward he came to my cell and seemed nervous. He brought in the New York Zeitung and said they have got another article about me. On my asking him he said the sheriff brought a man to his cell to him about Schulte's watch being found, and he (Buchholz) said he knew nothing at all about it; that we (Buchholz and Schulte) had not gone that way that night. At another time Buchholz showed me an article in the Zeitung, saying he did not like it all. I saw it and said to Buchholz, that looks bad for you. He said 'yes, this is the first time that the paper says I am or seem to be guilty of the murder. I wonder what new evidence they can have discovered to make them write so.' I tried to cheer him up. Another day Buchholz told me he owned a fine revolver he had purchased in lower New York, I think he said to protect himself and Schulte, adding that there were many tramps on the road between South Norwalk and Schulte's home. He said he had paid $9 for it. I said he could have got one cheaper at a pawn shop, but he said he didn't care; that if he had had that revolver the night of the murder he would have settled that fellow who attacked him. During the conversation I had about the watch I asked him if the matter was important, and he said no, and added he would like to know if his lawyers knew anything about it. He said he believed he could not sleep that night. He must write to his lawyers and see what they knew about the watch business. He said he did not believe any one could identify the watch, and that it was necessary to secure the personal attendance of persons to identify anything. [Hirscher had told Buchholz that a dispatch had been received from Germany identifying the watch by a private mark.]"
OTHER TESTIMONY.
At this point the testimony of Stark was broken off that witnesses who were anxious to go out of town immediately might be heard. Henry Bischoff, the banker, completed the identification of Schulte's money.
Conductor Edwin A. Wildman, who runs the 5:28 Shore Line express out of this city, to New York, testified that the train leaves South Norwalk at 6:24. It left at that hour at the time of the murder. According to his reports, the train left New Haven on time, and arrived at New York on time.
S. Greünwald, Buchholz's predecessor or Schulte's servant, testified that he saw Schulte sign the contract that was made between him and the deceased. He saw him write the name "Johann Heinrich Schulte."
Mr. Bollman – How do you pronounce the first name?
The witness – "Yo-hann."
Mr. Craw, clerk of the coroner's jury, was called to testify as to Buchholz's statements before the jury.
THE SOURCES OF CONNECTICUT'S CRIMES.
So frequent and startling have been the crimes recently committed in Connecticut that the press in other states begin to show symptoms of restiveness at Connecticut's claim that she is "the land of steady habits." For example, the New York Sun of to day says: "It is understood that the Rev. Herbert H. Hayden will suspend his course of lectures on "Circumstantial Evidence" long enough to stand a second trial for the murder of Mary E. Stannard. Years ago Connecticut used to take pride in the name of "the land of steady habits." It boasted of its munificent common school fund, which enabled all its sons and daughters to read, write, cipher and commit the Westminster catechism to memory. The Congregational clergy were called "the standing order," and were supported mainly by taxation. All the people went to meeting twice every Sunday; and it was reported by scoffers that on their return from Divine service the deacons were accustomed to whip their cider barrels for working during their absence. Connecticut is losing caste. One clergyman is about to be tried the second time for poisoning and cutting the throat of his mistress. One clergyman's wife is under indictment for blowing out the brains of her husband. One aristocratic church member has recently escaped by the skin of his teeth an indictment for poisoning his wife. Two zealous members of another church were not long since convicted and sentenced for embellishing their dwellings with elegant furniture stolen from the houses of their neighbors. It is about a year since a man and a woman of good repute, who were specially active at church fairs and Sunday school celebrations, were sent to the state prison for life, the former for poisoning his wife, the latter for poisoning her husband. The double crime was committed in order that the guilty pair might continue their intimacy undisturbed by the gossip of spies and suits for divorce. Indeed, so prevalent has the poisoning mania become in Connecticut that the learned professors of Yale college have to spend much of their time in analyzing the stomachs of citizens of that state who have been put to death by their fellow citizens.
Alas! for the Land of Steady Habits."
But the Sun seems to forget the reason for the apparent deterioration in Connecticut morals. When that reason is fully understood the fault will appear to be not Connecticut's, at least. Connecticut was “the land of steady habits" until the rapid growth of New York on the one side, and Massachusetts, on the other side, coupled with the cheap communication by rail and steamboat, caused an overflow of Massachusetts and New York people into Connecticut's borders. The low rents and cheap fares by rail and boat have brought a large New York population into the eastern part of the state, and it will be recollected that a large share of the atrocious crimes referred to by the Sun have been committed comparatively near the New York border. Buchholz, for instance, who is on trial at Bridgeport for the murder of Schulte, came directly from the city of New York to commit the crime, of which he is undoubtedly guilty. Connecticut gets the disgrace of the Buchholz murder, but a New York ruffian is guilty of the crime. Connecticut suffers in reputation also from the numerous Massachusetts people who have crossed the northern border and have located as far south as Hartford. While Massachusetts and New York have been chiefly instrumental in giving Connecticut a bad name, by sending their criminal classes to prey upon our innocent and rather rustic population, Rhode Island, on our eastern border, has helped not a little towards the demoralization of Connecticut morals. The long list of black crimes which the Sun refers to, if traced back, would, no doubt, in most cases, be found to have been committed by persons coming from New York, Massachusetts and Rhode Island, or else it would appear that the depraved morals which led to the commission of crimes by Connecticut criminals, was the result of outside contamination. We greatly fear that the usually impartial Sun has omitted to allow its light to shine into the sources of Connecticut crimes, or it would be more moderate in its assaults upon Connecticut's once fair reputation.
Yesterday's Third Edition
[This just starts like this, with no headline or dateline or any context at all]
Mr. Craw, clerk of the coroner's jury, was called to testify as to Buchholz's statements before the jury.
The witness had already read the first portion of Buchholz's statement, and Gen. Smith objected to his further testimony on the ground that Buchholz was in the custody of officers at the time of his giving his testimony.
A number of witnesses were put upon the stand to show the particulars of Buchholz's arrest. It appeared that Saturday, the day after the murder, while Buchholz was testifying, State Attorney Olmsted telegraphed to the jury: "Arrest Buchholz. Hold him until I come. James H. Olmsted, State Attorney." Members of the jury, however, thought best not to arrest him, but asked him if he would go with the officers, who would see he had everything he wanted, and could go wherever he wanted, except out of their sight. Buchholz readily accepted the agreement and went with the officers. At night he was locked up. The court ruled that the testimony was not admissible, as Buchholz was practically under arrest, as he understood that had he not gone willingly with the officers, they would have taken him by force. Statements made while he was under arrest were not admissible unless the prisoner had been warned what would be the consequences of his testimony. In that event his statements would be regarded as voluntary.
In the course of the arguments upon the admissibility of the testimony General Smith criticised the course of State Attorney Olmsted during the conduct of the coroner's jury in the most severe terms. He insinuated that the attorney in taking control of the jury without giving Buchholz, a stranger to the country and its customs, an opportunity to a fair hearing, had acted in a most inhuman manner. He did not speak so much on account of his client as for the sake of others who in future shall be involved in suspicious circumstances, as they are liable to be, until a different class of state attorney shall appear – (after a pause) than some that are known of.
Judge Loomis severely reproved the lawyer. He said the court was not disposed to listen to lectures upon state attorneys. General Smith apologized to both the court and to Mr. Olmsted.
Mr. Olmsted said he was governed in his action before the jury, by what he believed to be his duty as an officer of the state. In truth he thought not of this trial but of immediate consequences – the detection of the murderer. He would stand by all that he had done, and was willing that his children should inherit all the disgrace which should fall upon him, because of his course in this case.
This probably is the last of a series of angry wrangles between General Smith and Mr. Olmsted, that began at the former trial, and has continued almost daily.
Second Edition
THE DETECTIVE'S STORY.
----------
WHAT BUCHHOLZ TOLD HIM.
----------
Stark's Testimony Continued and Completed – How the Prisoner Threatened to Commit Suicide if He was Betrayed – Dreams that Turned Out to be Prophetic.
BRIDGEPORT, March 4. – Stark, the detective, was upon the witness stand all yesterday afternoon and completed his story at noon to-day.
Buchholz told him he had agreed to pay his lawyers $1,500, and when the witness told him he could have obtained counsel for a smaller sum, Buchholz replied that the money would make no difference if he could get clear. He told Stark that he had better employ his counsel, and after an interview Mr. Bollman agreed to defend him. One day Buchholz was complaining of being in jail and said, "I wish I was out for an hour, I would go and lift Schulte's treasure." The witness made no reply, and before long Buchholz put his arm around the detective's neck and said, “Oh how I wish I could get out for an hour. " Why; what would you do?" asked Stark; "would you go and lift Schulte's treasure." "Yes," was the reply. I would go to his gold mine. It is in my mattress. If I could get out I would let you have not $500, but $5,000. Buchholz described Schulte's wounds, which he said were made with an axe. He said there was a secret trap in Schulte's room between the windows. It opened when a spring was touched, and in it was a tin box containing $60,000. He said the greenbacks were marked, and Stark said he could erase the marks by acids. The witness looked doubtful, but finally said that if what Buchholz said was true, he would try and get out on bail. The witness left the jail May 15, being released upon bail. He visited Buchholz on an average of twice a week from that time until shortly before the trial, and told him that he would have to leave Bridgeport before the trial. At this the prisoner became worried, and said he would give $500 if Stark would attend to some matters for him. He said he wanted him to get $700 that he had put away. One pocketbook was in the Waring barn. He described the place, drew a diagram of the barn and told the witness he could get it in a minute. Stark went to the barn, put his hand through a hole in the floor and pulled out a pocketbook. He took it to New York and the German consul-general opened it at Pinkerton's detective agency; it contained $4,737 in American money. The next day Stark went to see Buchholz again and told him he had not been able to remove the marks which Schulte had placed upon the bills. He told Buchholz that he had borrowed $350 from a friend and would let him have it on his note. He told Buchholz that the Waring place was going to be sold and that the establishment would be turned upside down. Then Buchholz said they will find the other pocketbook; he said this book was thick and contained "thousands." He told Stark where to find it and he, Mr. Pinkerton, and an attaché of the German consulate. went to the barn and found the money.
Buchholz frequently expressed it as his opinion that Stark was a detective or a spy. He called him "Vidocq," 'if you are a detective you have me now' he said "but it will do you no good because I have the means of destroying myself in jail." The witness laughed at him, and told him not to commit suicide because he would not be betrayed. Another time he said he had been dreaming. He was in the court room and the lawyers had just finished examining the witnesses in the case and were about to make their pleas, when Mr. Olmsted got up and said "I have got one more witness to call" and he called out Stark's name. At this point he awoke. Another time he had a similar dream in which Stark was upon the witness stand testifying against him. At first he said he had a sore neck but finally said his chest pained him. He said he had been reading "Schiller's Robbers" and had stabbed himself in imitation of Carl Moor, the leader. The wound was serious enough to cause much bleeding, and Stark was alarmed for fear Buchholz had done more than he would tell and had actually committed suicide. He made the remark that if the time should ever come for suicide he would have a steady hand. On another occasion, expressing his fears that the witness would appear against him, he said if he saw him on the witness stand he would hurl a chair against him. Another time he said he would rise in the court room, make a statement and stab himself.
Another day he said if he couldn't kill himself any other way he would jump off a tier in the jail and dash his brains out against the pavement below.
At one time while he was outside the jail Stark told Buchholz that detectives were watching him and so he did not go to the Warring farm for the money. Buchholz said the jury must be bought up; that Stark ought to see the members and fix them.
Very frequently Buchholz was gloomy and downcast, and when Stark asked him whether the old man Schulte was troubling him he said "No, he is nothing to me."
"Does your conscience trouble you?" asked Stark.
"No, my conscience does not trouble me," said Buchholz. When the watch matter was spoken of, he laughed and said he had never had it in his hands. Stark asked him whether he would testify in his own behalf, and told him he would have to submit to a cross-examination. Buchholz replied that that was all right. Mr. Bollman, his counsel, had cross-examined him so thoroughly that he cornered him in many ways. Another time Buchholz said that the only ones who knew where the money was were Schulte and himself. He said he was not going to tell his lawyers about the money; he wasn't such a fool as that. He should get the money himself first. When Stark first asked him to tell him where the money was he retused, but said, "If I get a life sentence I'll tell you, because it will do me no good then."
Once Buchholz said to Stark, "Do you think you and I will ever be happy with this money." Stark said "why certainly, why shouldn't be." "Well, said Buchholz, sometimes I think we should be happy with it." On several occasions he told Stark that if he went back on him and testified against him he could only testify to the fact of the stealing of the money; that he had told him nothing about the murder. At one time he said Stark could have $10,000 of the money; he would keep the balance.
Stark testified that the last visit he made to the Waring farm was on the 16th of last month. He dug under one of the stalls and found some remnants of paper. They seemed to be pieces of newspapers and were exhibited in court. Further testimony will be introduced concerning them. General Smith then took the witness, but did not succeed in drawing much from him beyond the fact, that though he had used his best endeavors and gained the confidence of Buchholz he failed to extort from him any confession of the murder.
Stark in the course of his answers gave it as his opinion that Buchholz killed Schulte. He said he went into the jail perfectly impartial; his instructions were to find out the truth of a Schulte affair. At one time Buchholz said Schulte's wound was inflicted with a hatchet. At another he told Stark that his lawyers, Smith and Bollman had talked so earnestly with him warning him not to talk about the case with anyone that he was on the point of telling them that he had confided to him (Stark). Stark advised him not to tell them of it; that they would get all of this money.
Mr. Smith – Did you have any grounds for such an assertion?
The witness – None whatever.
Gen. Smith – Did you ever have any reason to think his lawyers ever got any of the Schulte money?
The witness – No, sir. One day Buchholz said he had a great mind to return the money either to the Schulte heirs or else to the authorities.
Dr. Leonard J. Sanford of New Haven was called to testify concerning one of the bones taken from the Schulte skull. He thought there were two wounds and that one of them was inflicted by a blunt instrument like the butt end of an axe. The Schulte hat, in which was shown a cut, was handled by the doctor, who thought the cut was made by the edge of the axe or by one just like it. There were irregularities in the cut which conformed to those in the edge of the axe.
DRAWING TO A CLOSE
----------
MR. OLMSTED FINISHES HIS CASE.
----------
Buchholz's Defense Begun – Dr. Treadwell's Testimony Called in Question – Did Buchholz have a Chance to Rob Schulte's Body While it was being Carried Home.
BRIDGEPORT, March 5. – The lawyers who are defending Buchholz did not expect that State Attorney Olmsted would close his case without another surprise of some sort; and they were right; the suddenness with which he brought his case to an end was a genuine surprise. Dr. Sanford's testimony was given in yesterday's report. He was followed by Robert A. Pinkerton, under whose orders Stark, the detective, acted. He said he was employed to send a detective to the Bridgeport jail by the German consul-general in New York, who was acting as attorney for Schulte's brother in Germany. Stark was told to find out all he could about Buchholz, whether favorable to him or otherwise. The witness detailed the finding of the Schulte money in the Waring barn, and described the arrangements he made to make Stark's arrest and incarceration in the Bridgeport jail. The agent in New York of the Adams Express company telegraphed to the Bridgeport office to arrest the party who called for a money package. Stark was told to refuse to answer questions and make as much mystery about himself and his business as possible.
The state then rested, and the defense called Samuel Waring. He testified that the axe with which it is claimed by the state that Buchholz killed Mr. Schulte, was taken from the Waring house the day after the murder and kept three weeks. Then it was returned and was used for chopping wood for some time. The handle got split in some way and the witness tried to remove it. The large part of the broken handle was wrenched off. Then he sawed off the remaining fragment up close to the axe, being unable to pull it out. There it was still remaining, the end of the handle in the iron. This he could not get out, so he put the axe into the kitchen stove. He lifted the stove lid, put the axe in, and then put the lid on again. He left it there ten or twelve minutes, and then took it out and, as it was very hot, put it in a pail of water. The wood had been burned out. Then he took the axe to the Dingee house and ground it thoroughly, one of his sisters going with him. He left no kinks in the edge like those which now existed in it.
Mr. Olmsted subjected the witness to a lengthy cross-examination, and succeeded in confusing him, but although he became somewhat mixed, he persisted in the truth of his statements. Mr. Olmsted plainly intimated that the story was a fabrication in his opinion.
If the story is accepted as true by the jury, it will knock to pieces the testimony of the experts, Drs. Treadwell and Sanford. The former testified that he found corpuscles of mammalian blood upon the axe, but the state will hardly claim that the blood of Mr. Schulte's and it survives a hot fire, immersion in water, a thorough grinding and several months service at the chopping block, and Dr. Sanford's testimony that the irregularities in the cut in the Schulte hat correspond exactly to the kinks and indentations in the edge of the axe is worthless if Samuel Waring is to be credited. The witness looked like an honest fellow who didn't know much: his remarkable manner of removing the axe handle does not indicate that he is possessed of a superabundance of sense.
The first witness called this morning was Conductor Edwin F. Strickland, who ran the 5:15 train out of New York December 27, 1878, the train upon which Mr. Schulte came to South Norwalk. The train was due at South Norwalk at 6:48 and was on time when it left New York and reached New Haven on time.
Prof. Julius M. Ellenhorf of South Norwalk testified that he gave English lessons to Buchholz from the middle of October, 1878, to the day of the murder; fourteen lessons in all. He gave him his last lesson the day of the murder. Buchholz's demeanor was as usual that day. At that time he could speak a few English phrases indistinctly, but could not carry on a conversation. The witness was asked to give his views concerning the translation of proper names, and said some persons, who changed their place of residence from one country to another, changed their names, while others did not.
A number of witnesses were called to describe the carrying of the body of Schulte from the woods to the Waring house, the object being to show that Buchholz had hold of the body while it rested upon the stone wall, while the carriers were climbing over. The claim of the defense is that while the body rested upon the wall Buchholz saw one of Schulte's pocketbooks sticking out of one of his coat-tail pockets, and slipped it into his own overcoat pocket. Simon Reynolds, Charles Shariss, Frank Mayhen and W. H. Richards, all saw the removal of the body, and testified that Buchholz had hold near the stone wall; one of them was sure Buchholz had hold of the shoulder while the body rested on the wall. There were two lanterns in the crowd, one of which was carried ahead of the party. Richards saw Buchholz and Schulte pass along the railroad track and turn off towards the woods the evening of the tragedy. Buchholz was 15 or 20 feet ahead. It was shortly after the 6:24 train had passed by. Gustavus Pitzer is proprietor of a barber shop in
South Norwalk, which at the time of the murder adjoined the saloon of Paul Hirscher. He saw Schulte and Buchholz in the saloon the evening of the murder the 6:11 train got in. While waiting for Schulte Buchholz had played with one of the witness' little children; his demeanor was as usual. The witness thought Buchholz and Schulte spent ten or twelve minutes in the saloon drinking beer. He could see them from his shop by an open iron way. Pitzer assisted in carrying the body to the house. He knows that Buchholz had hold of the body at the stone wall. After the body had been deposited in the Waring house the witness saw Buchholz sitting down and crying. When asked how the affair occurred he said that he and Schulte had been attacked down in the woods. He said he was ahead and heard Schulte call out "Buchholz, Bucholz." Then he was attacked by two men, one of whom struck him. He was not sure but that there were three men. He ran up toward the barn and one of the men said. "Greenhorn, I'll catch you yet."
Mr. Pitzer said he had heard many rumors concerning Schulte's wealth. Many thought it strange that he should dress the way he did, when he carried so much money about him. Grüenwald told the witness that Schulte was very wealthy.
The witness was cross-examined at great length. Both he and the witnesses who preceded him were shown to have testified differently as to some details at the former trial. George B. Talmadge testified that he was in Hirscher's saloon the evening of the murder, when Schulte came in followed soon after by Buchholz. He thought they remained there ten minutes.
THE BUCHHOLZ TRIAL.
----------
Denying Heineman's Testimony – The Waring Axe.
BRIDGEPORT, March 6. – At the conclusion of the REGISTER's report of yesterday I. Mortimer Hoyt testified as to the finding of the axe in Mrs. Waring's barn. It looked as though it had been used to cut off chicken's heads, being stained with blood, and having fowl feathers attached. The witness understood that Schulte always carried a large amount of money about his person, and this fact was very generally known. When he paid for the house in which Mrs. Waring lived, he took $5,000 from a bundle of bills in his belt and handed it over to the person from whom he made the purchase. Common rumor said that he was in the habit of carrying all the money he possessed in his pockets or secreted in his belt. Lewis J. Blake corroborated the testimony of the preceding witness as to the finding the axe, and its condition. He added that it was very dull. Dr. William C. Burke of South Norwalk, also examined the blade of the axe immediately after the murder. He used a powerful magnifying glass, and looked for hairs. He found none, and he was assured that there were none there. There were dried blood and feathers, but nothing more.
Mrs. Waring was recalled by the defence, at her own request, to make certain corrections in her former testimony. She had originally been a witness for the prosecution, and, in view of that circumstance, the state’s attorney said it was a little remarkable that she should go to the prisoner’s counsel with her explanation. He objected to her giving any testimony on the subject of the axe, and Gen. Smith, the prisoner’s counsel, said the state’s attorney should not attempt, in a capital case, to impeach his own witness. The state’s attorney was about to reply but Chief Justice Park said the court did not care to hear any more recriminations between counsel. After some further very warm words between the lawyers, Mrs. Waring went on to corroborate her son’s testimony with regard to burning the stump out of the blade of the axe. She saw him put it into the fire, leave it there some time, and take it out. When she next saw it there was a new handle in it, and her son and daughter were going out to sharpen it. Miss Sadie Waring also testified that her brother had put the axe in the fire, after sawing the handle off to burn out the stump. The witness then went with her brother to a neighbor’s house and she turned the grindstone while “Sammy” ground the axe. He ground it for twenty minutes, and until two or three deep dents in it had been almost ground out.
Henry Frederick Shibley, a young man who had been absent from his native city for a period of eight months, and had just come from the Bridgeport jail, where he had been a prisoner, was the next witness. His testimony was a direct denial of the statement in court by the prisoner Hineman, that there had been no conversation between him and the witness about Buchholz’s case. Hineman, the witness said, had told him that he would testify against Buchholz, as it would help his case, and it would not Buchholz, for “he would have to swing anyway.”
Hineman, being put on the stand, said that he had played a good joke on Shibley, and that was the cause of the latter’s animosity against him.
THE BUCHHOLZ TRIAL
----------
TESTIMONY FOR THE DEFENSE.
----------
The Three Men Who Were Seen About South Norwalk the Day of the Murder – Evidence About the Overalls – A Boy With a Strange Story.
BRIDGEPORT, March 9. – Henry Shibby, the young Englishman who testified last week that Heineman, the alleged forger, had told him in the Bridgeport jail that he was going to testify against Buchholz, in the hope that it would better his own case, was called to the stand again yesterday afternoon that he might be cross-examined by State Attorney Olmsted. He was hall man in the jail at the time that, as he alleges Heineman made this statement to him, and had only just been released. When he took the stand he was somewhat under the influence of liquor and was very short in his replies to state attorney. “What did Heineman say to you” was asked. “I told it all the other day” was the reply, "if you want it again you had better read your notes." A few more answers of that sort brought out threats that the witness would be sent back to jail if he continued in his course, and he then changed his mind and repeated the conversation he had with Heineman. He went further than this, and testified to still another conversation that he had with the alleged forger. "Why didn't you testify to that before," asked Mr. Olmstead. "Because," replied the witness, "I was not asked about." Were you not sworn to tell the whole truth?" "The court adjourned before I could tell it."
The witness said he could not remember whether he had ever told anybody that he had been arrested in England for stabbing his father.
A justice of the peace testified that Graff, another prisoner who testified against Buchholz, when brought before him, said that his father was living on Long Island. While on the stand Gaff said he was a native of Venezuela and that his father died there.
Sadie Waring was recalled to correct an error she said she had unintentionally made in her testimony. She had said that Sammy, her brother, hammered the axe to get the stump of the handle out of it after he put it into the fire. She meant to say that he hammered it before putting it into the fire. The stump was burnt out by the fire. This is the axe on which was found the corpuscles of blood by Dr. Treadwell.
Nathaniel Bouton testified that about a month before the murder of Schulte he saw a rag on the ground thirty feet from where the body was bound. He was shown part of a shirt that had been picked up, stained with blood, near the same place, immediately after the murder, and he thought it was like the rag he had formerly seen.
Josiah Triston [Tristram] testified that he, soon after the murder, close to the place where according to the prosecuting Schulte's watch was found, but he did not see the watch.
Daniel L. Mallard, principal of the public school in Brooklyn, N. Y., was in South Norwalk on the day of the murder. While walking on the track in the evening he saw three tramps near a great rock, and one of them was trying to kindle a fire. They were all desperate looking characters. One of them had dark whiskers, and another lighter ones. The witness did not feel quite safe when he saw them, and he went back. One of them had on a pair of dirty overalls. He did not notice the clothing of the others. Mr. Olmstead asked the witness if it was not quite as likely that the three men thought he was a dangerous looking character as that they were such. He insisted that they were dangerous looking men: they impressed him as being men capable of committing a desperate crime. He thought one of the men averted his head when he saw the witness.
Stephen Oeshader [Ostrader] of South Norwalk testified that he was in the woods on the afternoon of the murder. He saw, near some rocks, three men who looked like tramps. While the witness was looking at them they put torn and dirty clothing over better ones. They spoke in a foreign language and broken English. One of them said he might as well be in South Norwalk as there, and he accordingly went away. This was between two and three o'clock in the afternoon. The men saw him, but continued changing their clothing, paying little attention to him.
At the opening of the court this morning General Smith said he desired to obtain a deposition from New York to show that a man giving a certain name sailed for Germany at a certain date.
Mr. Olmstead agreed to admit as evidence the printed list of the steamship company to show that N. Abel sailed for Germany on the steamship Oder, Saturday, May 10, 1879.
Leander G. Wilcox of South Norwalk, testified that on the morning of the day of the murder he saw two men standing on the Spring street bridge over the railroad tracks. They stood two or three minutes and one of them pointed down the track. One had black military whiskers, black hair and a black coat. He had on light overalls, the witness thought made of No. 9 Dick, which appeared to be entirely new, being without spots or wrinkles. Another man had on a pair of salmon-colored overalls, which also appeared to be new.
The pair of new overalls which were found near the scene of the murder were shown to the witness. He said the shade was the same, but he thought the overalls shown in court were not made of Dick but of some unbleached court. He could not be sure whether the overalls were the same or not, but they resembled one another.
Mr. Wilcox saw the men again in the afternoon. They were well dressed about the neck, having on clean collars and nice neckties.
Benjamin M. Wilcox, a son of the preceding witness saw the men in the morning and afternoon. They passed him on the railroad track speaking together in a foreign language. They were going towards New York. When he first saw them they were at the depot: When he saw them the second time they had on overalls. Before this they did not. One man, who was about six feet tall, had on light overalls. The witness thought they resembled the ones shown in court. He identified them by the wrinkles made by putting them over the boots. Under the overalls the man wore green speckled pants tucked into the boots, The witness saw the men on the bridge. The tallest one appeared to be nervous and restless and walked to and fro. One of them went into Chester F. Tolles' place to get something to eat.
On the cross-examination the witness said he belonged to the American-European Secret Service company. His duty was to detect crime, look out for whatever was going on in the criminal way and report to the company. He receives pay only when he detects crime. When a reward is paid he gets one-third. He never had got any pay, never having been instrumental in bringing to justice any criminal for whom a reward was offered. He is the agent for a detective paper published by the company. The witness said he took it to the Waring house and placed it under lock and key. There was blood upon it but no feathers. After two or three weeks he returned it to either Mr. or Mrs. Waring.
On the 26th and 27th of December, 1878 – the murder occurred on the 27th – the witness counted more than 250 tramps go by his house on the railroad tracks.
Mary R. Dingee testified that one day subsequent to the murder, Sammy Waring came to her house to sharpen an ax upon the grindstone, which was used by many of the neighbors. Something was said by the witness about the murder. [The remark is supposed to have been "I wonder if that is the axe by which Schulte was killed." The witness was not allowed to repeat the remark in court.] The witness' testimony was to corroborate the testimony of Sam Waring and the Waring girls.
John Kreiling, proprietor of the Sonne hotel, an emigrants' boarding house in New York, testified that Buchholz came to his hotel in August, 1878. When Schulte came to the hotel he was accompanied by his servant, Greunwald. The latter left Schulte on account of some trouble; he had trouble in getting the money that was owing him. Previous to Schulte's going to South Norwalk, the witness told him he had better take Buchholz with him as his servant. Buchholz owed something for his board, and the witness thought he had better be earning something. Mr. Kreiling talked with Buchholz about it and advised him to go with Schulte. Before this, Buchholz had shown no disposition to go with him, as far as the witness knew.
Eli J. Savage, a boy about fourteen years of age, who works in the office of Dr. Kendall, a South Norwalk dentist, testified that Benjamin Wilcox called his attention to two men who stood upon the Spring street bridge on the day of the murder. He went up to them: One had dark whiskers and piercing black eyes. "He seemed to look right through me," said the boy. He had on a pair of brand new, light overalls. The witness thought those shown in court very like those worn by the man. That evening the witness was walking on the railroad track when the 6:11 train came along, going towards the South Norwalk depot, About the middle of the train he saw something white flutter, from the window. It might have been a handkerchief, and it might have been a piece of paper thrown out. After the train passed by he saw a man come out on to the track, and he thought he stooped down. The witness walked towards New York, going home by the way of the track. Pretty soon the man who had stooped down overtook him and passed him. Soon the boy came upon three men, one of whom had just passed him. One came out onto the track and then went back. Then the three stood in a group. The witness recognized the two men whom he had seen on the bridge. The tall man, the one with the light overalls hailed him, and the following conversation took place:
Man in Overalls – "What time is it?"
Eli – "Oh – between six and half-past."
Man – "What train was that just went by?'
Eli – "The 6:11."
Man – "Does the night express stop at the next two stations?"
Eli – "I don't know."
Man – "How far is it to the second bridge?"
Eli – "Fifteen to twenty minutes walk, good walking."
Man – "How far is it to Stamford?"
Eli – "I don't know."
Man – "What do you know?"
Eli – "That I am talking to a d– fool.”
The witness said that during the conversation one of the men said in broken English, “come its fifteen minutes." He thought the man was a German. One of them kept striking his pants with what seemed to be a piece of telegraph wire or two or three pieces twisted together. Soon after the men passed along Schulte and Buchholz came along, going towards the path leading to the Waring house. They were going in the same direction as the men. Buchholz was ten feet ahead and carrying something in his hand. Schulte had a satchel in his hand.
Question – Did you know Schulte?
Witness – Yes, in this way: when Schulte passed along I heard people say there goes the traveling gold mine.
The cross-examination developed the fact that the witness and two men named Benjamin Ayres and Beers had concocted a plan to get money out of the case by this and other evidence relating to a hatchet which was found in a tree near the scene of the murder. That the boy once went to New York and stayed there until Gen. Smith came for him and brought him back, his object in going being to compel the lawyers to pay him for his testimony. He gave his reason why he did not testify before that he was afraid of Mr. Olmstead’s cross-examination. It was also shown that the boy at the time of going to New York wrote in a disguised hand to Gen. Smith that he would be at a certain place on Eighth avenue, in New York, if wanted; that his father wanted him to go on a vessel to Virginia. The witness admitted this was not true. It appeared that either the boy was lying or else that the men Ayres and Beers had tried to use him to forward their plans for getting money out of one side or the other in the case. The boy could give no very satisfactory reason why he did not tell some one of what he had seen. Although he admitted that when he heard that Schulte had been killed the thought occurred to him that the men he had seen might have had something to do with it.
THE TRIAL OF BUCHHOLZ.
----------
FINISHING UP THE DEFENSE.
----------
The Importance of the Question of Time – Tracing a Mysterious Stranger Who May Have Been One of the Murders – Contradicting Eli Savage – Possibility that the Arguments Will Come To-morrow.
BRIDGEPORT, March 10. – The defense in the Buchholz case rested this morning and the prospect now is that the arguments will be begun to-morrow and that the case will be given to the jury by Friday night or Saturday morning. The defense has made out a stronger case than at the former trial. Buchholz's lawyers will claim to have shown that Buchholz did not have time to murder Schulte and rob him and reach the Waring house at the time it is said he did. They will also claim that they have shown that three suspicious looking character were hovering about South Norwalk on the day of the murder. They were seen by many. During the day time they tried to appear like tramps, or workmen, or, at least, different than they really were, by putting on overalls, one pair at least was new. The day after the murder a pair of new overalls were found within forty feet of where the body lay. There is evidence to show that the men, or part of them, were Germans. It has been shown that a stranger who came from the part of Germany where Schulte resident came to this country with a resident of South Norwalk named Illing, and was very intimate with him. The stranger was very mysterious. No one but Illing knew him; he came here in November and returned in the May following after the Schulte watch was found. Illing has lately disappeared and is said to be in Europe. The theory of the defence is that Schulte was killed by a party of four or five who supposed at the time they had secured all his money. Pocket books in his skirt tail pockets were, however, overlooked, and were subsequently taken by Buchholz.
Mr. Olmstead said this noon that he should call Dr. Treadwell on his arrival here soon after four o'clock this afternoon, and that would, as far as he knows, complete his witnesses.
THE QUESTION OF TIME.
As in many capital cases the question of time is a most important one in the trial of Buchholz; it is made even more important at this trial than at the first one. If the claim of the defense is correct, Buchholz did not have time enough on the night of December 27, 1879, to murder John H. Schulte, rob him, hide the pocketbooks in the barn, and then run to the Waring house. If the theory of the defense as given below is the true one, Buchholz must have robbed the body subsequent to the murder, while the body was being examined by the Waring neighbors and while it was being carried to the Waring house; and this is what he claims he did. Neither the claims of the state nor the defense as to this matter of time have been fully brought out at the present trial. When the lawyers reach the summing up their respective claims will be more clearly advanced. At the first trial the state made very evident what its claim was; the theory of the defense was not so fully developed as at present.
It is agreed by both sides that Schulte arrived at South Norwalk on the evening of the murder at 6:11 p. m. Buchholz joined him in Hirscher's saloon across from the depot soon after, and they drank beer together. There is a discrepancy as to the time spent by the two men in the saloon. A number of witnesses for the defense say they were there ten minutes; Hirscher thinks the time was less than that. Assuming for the present that the figures of the defense are correct, and 6:21 is reached. Mary Downey, a witness for the state, testified she saw Schulte and Buchholz pass along the railroad track; she saw them leave the track and take the usual path leading to the Waring house through the woods. Five or six minutes later she looked at her clock; it was 6:40. That her clock was correct she knows by the fact that she looked at it when one of the trains passed by that day; it was then keeping good time. Then Schulte and Buchholz passed her at 6:35 or 6:36. The distance from Hirscher's to where Mary Downey stood is half way to the second stone wall as it is known in the case. This is the place where Buchholz claims he was attacked by two men, and where he heard Schulte cry out, "Buchholz, Buchholz." So the defense assumes that as it took the two men thirteen or fourteen minutes to walk to where they passed Miss Downey, it would have taken Buchholz at least as long to walk from there to the stone wall. As the path from the railroad back to the wall is partly up hill it might, so it is claimed, have taken him longer. Taking the time as the same, Buchholz would have been at the wall at 6:47 or 6:48. Buchholz says he ran at the top of his speed from the wall to the Waring house. When Messrs. Dayton and Crow tried the experiment they made the distance in one minute and a half. Assuming that Buchholz was no quicker, he arrived at the house at 6:48 ½ or 6:49 ½. Now Mrs. Waring testified that she heard the quarter past seven train as it is called, pass the house before Buchholz appeared. The conductor testifies it passes the house at about 6:44 ½. Within five minutes of the train went by, so Mrs. Waring testifies, Buchholz came panting into the house. If it was fully five minutes then he arrived at 6:49 ½, and the theory of the defense is complete.
To recapitulate:
Schulte arrived … 6:11
Left Hirscher's … 6:21
Passed Miss Downey … 6:34 or 6:35
Buchholz reached the stone wall … 6:47 or 6:48
Buchholz reached Waring's … 6:48 ½ or 6:49 ½
Mrs. Waring's estimate … Not later than 6:49 ½
If the state claims that less than ten minutes was passed in Hirscher's, the defense will respond "so much the better for us." For then more time must have been spent in going to where Miss Downey stood; and assuming the same rate of speed was maintained through the woods – and it being dark and the path up hill, it is not probable that they would have gone faster – Buchholz would have reached the stone-wall and the Waring house still later than by the above calculation.
But the defense will present still another claim. The military regulation step is 28 inches; 80 of them are taken to the minute. Those who went over the ground for the state testify they took 124 steps to the minute, and made the distance in 21 minutes and a fraction. The distance is 7,514 feet. The defense figure that, according to their own figures, they took 124 steps of between 34 and 35 inches to the step per minute, and that this is very fast walking – much faster than Schulte and Buchholz were walking when seen by Miss Downey and Mr. Richards. Messrs. Dayton and Crow made the distance in 27 minutes – 25 ½ to the stone-wall, and from there 1 ½ to the Waring house.
Mr. Bollman uses a metronome, an instrument used to measure time in music, to illustrate how rapidly the men who walked over the ground for the state must have stepped, and thinks it shows very fast walking.
INTERESTING TESTIMONY.
Conductor Edwin N. Hunt testified yesterday afternoon that on the night of the Schulte murder two men, apparently Germans, got on his train at Stamford at 10:30 p. m. They seemed to have been running, were out of breath. They paid their fares to New Haven, One had a light beard, and the other a dark, well-trimmed one. On the following Sunday morning the witness saw the shorter of the two men get into the early train at New Haven and ride to New York.
Dr. Edward T. Ward of Bridgeport had examined, as an expert, the axe, the old hat, and the bones that had previously been examined by the experts subpoenaed by the state, and he had read the testimony already given on the subject. He produced a skull and placed upon it the old soft hat worn by Schulte at the time of the murder. In the witness' opinion the cut upon the hat was not made by the axe produced in court. The cut was a clean, sharp one, and could not possibly have been made by so blunt an instrument as an axe.
Dr. Robert Hubbard of Bridgeport, a leading surgeon, examined the bones taken from Schulte's head, and said he did not think they had been broken by so blunt an instrument as the axe. A thin, sharp instrument, such as a sabre, would have caused such a wound.
Jeremiah Donovan of South Norwalk testified that when Paul Hirscher and a number of other liquor dealers were arrested. Hirscher told the witness that he would pay no money into the common fund for the defense of the dealers, because the state's attorney would be obliged to let him get off. Soon afterward the witness met Hirscher at Bridgeport; and the latter said he had "made it all right."
Several witnesses examined by the defense to show that about the time of the murder a man named Moritz Abel, whom nobody had seen before or since, went to South Norwalk and disappeared without giving any notice that he was going away. He stayed some time in Bridgeport before going to South Norwalk, boarding near the depot in both places. He left his boarding house in Bridgeport without paying his bill. He returned to Germany May 10.
----------
The first witness called to the stand this morning was State Attorney Olmstead, who was asked if he sent Illing to Moritz Abel, among whose effects a card was found with Charles Illing's name upon it. He objected to telling what messenger he may have sent upon any errand connected with the case.
Gen. Smith stated that it had been shown that Illing had had much to do with the case and was the man who removed Buchholz's clothing and overhauled his effects. At the former trial the defense expected that he would appear as a witness, but he went over the state line. At the present time he is in Germany.
The testimony was ruled out.
Mr. Olmstead was asked whether he had in his possession any memoranda, letters or papers taken from the body of Schulte, his effects or the ground near where the body lay.
He replied that he knew of none in his possession or under his control.
Gen. Smith said he had been promised by Walter C. Quintard, the administrator of the Schulte estate, a chance to examine certain memoranda obtained from the body of Schulte, Mr. Quintard agreeing to obtain them from the state attorney.
Mr. Olmstead said he did not know to what the gentleman referred.
The court ruled that the defense was entitled to the papers and Mr. Quintard was telegraphed for.
Mr. Olmstead was asked by Gen. Smith if he received the other day an anonymous letter, enclosed in which was another addressed to him (Smith), whether the envelope was addressed to Olmstead or Smith.
Mr. Olmstead objected to replying on the ground that the letters had nothing to do with the case and that whatever he handed to Gen. Smith was not handed to him in open court. The objection was sustained.
Albert Winter, a Bridgeport brewer testified that he came over from Hamburg, Germany, on the steamer Gellert in November 1878, leaving on the 6th and arriving on the 20th. On board of the steamer were Detective Illing and Abel.
"Why do you call him Detective Illing?"
"I found out that he seemed to be a detective afterward; I found it out two or three days after the murder of Schulte. Abel and Illing were intimate and almost always together when on the steamer. I saw them both together in Bridgeport after my arrival here. I saw them at Wagner's. I could not tell from what part of Germany he came by his dialect. He called himself Abel of Cologne."
The defense sought to secure the admission of the book found in Abel's effects left at his boarding place in Bridgeport in order to show that he had canvassed a district in Westphalia, Germany, and visited the towns adjoining Schulte's residence. It did not come out what he was a canvasser for, whether a mercantile house or a book concern, but it is understood that it was the latter.
The will of Johann Heinrich Schulte was read and offered in evidence to show what his name was, and what interest certain parties would have in his death. It was read as follows:
Schulte's Will, Published Hagen Jan. 23 1879
No 5-75, Signed Hesse, Judicial Councillor
II 1428
LAST WILL AND TESTAMENT.
In case I should leave this life prematurely, I hereby bequeath my whole estate, both personal and real, credits and debits, to my only surviving brother the proprietor F. W. Schulte of Grossenholthausen. In case my said brother should die before me then and in that case I leave all my property to my next of kin. I leave this world conscious of having always acted right and fulfilled my duty and not feeling any remorse by ignoring and annulling in this will the legal validity and consequences of the decree of the county court at Hagen dated December 18, 1861, judicially declaring me the father of a bastard as well as the other decrees rendered against me.
(Signed)
JOH. HEIN. SCHULTE
proprietor
Boelerheide the fifth day
of December 1873
Mr. Olmstead was called to the stand again.
Gen. Smith – "Are you and have you been since the murder counsel for Schulte's brother in Germany?"
Mr. Olmstead – "I don't know how to answer that question. If you desire I will state the circumstances."
Gen. Smith – "Answer yes or no."
Mr. Olmstead – "I can't answer the question in that way. If I am allowed to explain –"
Gen. Smith – "Who probated the will in the Norwalk probate court?"
Mr. Olmstead – "I did –"
Gen Smith – "That is all."
Mr. Olmstead – "I was retained by the German consul after the money was found and I suppose that covered the brother of Schulte also."
Gen. Smith – "I presume so."
Gen. Smith attempted to introduce an extract from Schulte's diary, dated September 1, 1878, a short time before he left for this country. It contains an account of the night attack upon his bedroom by a party of five armed men, including his nephew, one of whom fired through his window, but did not hit him, owing to his watchfulness and habit of rising early. The diary contains an account of a second attack made upon his life by some one who fired stones through his window. Gen. Smith did not claim that technically it was admissible, but said if it could be brought in it would, in his opinion, have more effect upon the jury than two or three days of solid testimony.
Mrs. Waring testified that Dec. 25, 1878, the day before the murder, Buchholz killed a chicken for her with the family axe. His hands were bloody and he wiped them on his pants.
A map of part of Germany was exhibited to show the position of Westphalia, and the proximity of Hagan to Cologne.
Mr. Olmstead was asked if he had two telegrams sent from the brother in Germany, to Mr. Quintard or Mayor Hanford after the murder of Schulte, and replied he had not.
Gen. Smith said with the exception of certain memoranda which they desired to introduce, the defense rested.
REBUTTAL.
Mr. Olmstead called George Graff, one of the prisoners in the Bridgeport jail, who testified against Buchholz, in rebuttal.
Mr. Olmstead – "Justice Boughton testified that you stated before him that you had a father and step-mother living on Long Island. Is that so?"
The witness – "I don't believe I ever spoke to the gentleman at all. He must have got it from others. I've got a step mother just the same. The man whom I call my father married my step mother who lives on Long Island."
John H. Wells, alias Heineman, the alleged forger, was called and asked if he ever told Shrivley, the hall man at the jail, that he was going to testify that Buchholz confessed to him that he murdered and robbed Schulte. "I never spoke to Shrivley about it in any shape, manner or form," was his answer.
"How lately have you seen Shrivley?"
"To-day; he is in jail again on another charge."
Benjamin F. Wilcox was recalled.
Mr. Olmstead – "Did Eli J. Savage ever tell you you could make $50 by finding the hatchet by which Schulte was killed?"
The witness – " He did."
Mr. Olmstead – "This was before the hatchet was found up the tree?"
The witness – "It was."
Mr. Olmstead – "Did he tell you that if you had important testimony you could sell it to the state attorney, and advised you to get your money before you told what you knew?"
The Witness – "He did."
General Smith – "You had told about seeing the men with the overalls long before this?"
The Witness – "Yes sir."
Yesterday’s Third Edition
The Bucholz Trial.
Benjamin M. Ayers, the man who it is claimed by the defense attempted to manufacture evidence to get money out of one side of the case or the other, and who corrupted the boy Eli Savage, testified that Eli told him that on the night of the murder he saw a piece of white paper thrown from the 6:11 train into South Norwalk, and saw a man pick it up, read it and go off. Ayers denied that he had ever advised Eli to go New York so as to compel Gen. Smith to follow him and pay him for his testimony, but he understood the boy to say that he was going to New York for that purpose. He bought the boy a ticket for New York but used his (Eli's) money for the purpose, and did not suggest the matter to the boy until he asked him to make the purchase. The witness said he was not positive whether or not the boy first broached the idea of inserting an advertisement in the Norwalk Sentinel, to the effect that upon the payment of a reward, the hatchet with which Schulte was killed would be produced.
The witness was asked if there was a piece of white paper found in the eye of the hatchet found in the tree. General Smith objected, and said if the veracity of the boy Eli was to be called into question, he should himself go upon the stand and tell something he knew about the case. The witness was allowed to answer, and testified that there was no piece of paper there.
On the cross-examination the witness said he picked up the hatchet which fell from the tree. Two weeks later Ell spoke of having seen a piece of paper in the eye. There was a piece of lead in the eye. Something was said about if there was a reward offered we ought to get it. The witness said he did not know who first proposed getting a reward. He was asked whether Eli didn't come to him after the notice appeared in the Sentinel and say, "This is a pretty job you are putting up on me," but the question was ruled out. When the hatchet was found Eli said, "better throw it in the swamp;" he didn't say "better keep it to get a reward." The hatchet was kept in the possession of the witness until delivered up to the state.
David Beers, who accompanied Ayers and Eli on the trip when the hatchet, as alleged, was found – it is generally thought that the whole affair was a put-up job, and that Ayers only pretended to find the hatchet – corroborated the other witnesses in regard to Eli's statements as to what he saw flutter or drop from the 6:11 train on the night of the murder. He saw Ayers when he claimed he found the hatchet. Ayers claimed he found a hair upon it, and said a reward ought to be obtained for it.
General Smith – "Who put up this job?"
The Witness – "That's what I should like to find out."
General Smith – “Well, I can tell you."
Second Edition
TALKING TO THE JURY.
----------
IS BUCHHOLZ MORE THAN A THIEF?
----------
The Opening Arguments for the State and the Defense – The Prisoner Weeping Bitterly – Mr. Bollman's Presentation of the Law and Analysis of the Testimony – He Pleads Strongly for His Client.
BRIDGEPORT, March 11. – It was after four o'clock yesterday afternoon when Dr. J. R. Treadwell, the blood stain expert, took the witness stand in the Buchholz case. He said he had read in the papers that the axe upon which he found mammalian blood corpuscles had been placed in the fire of a kitchen stove. So he determined to try an experiment to learn the effect of heat upon blood corpuscles, and covered the blade and blade shank of a common knife with blood from his own veins, allowed it to dry between two and three days, and then subjected it to heat sufficient to char the wood. He found that some of the corpuscles were fused, that is changed into a homogeneous mass, but the remainder were unchanged. He had no difficulty in distinguishing the shape and form of the corpuscles.
The doctor said he had many years experience as a surgeon and had frequently seen clean cuts made by blunt instruments, as a brick or policeman's billy.
THE ARGUMENTS.
The arguments were begun at 9 o'clock this morning by Nelson Taylor, Jr., associate attorney for the state. He began by defining the crime of murder and murder in the first degree. That this was a willful and deliberate murder is admitted by both sides, and the two witnesses requisite to prove murder in the first degree and much more have been offered by the state, which has effectually attempted to build a wall of evidence about William Buchholz. There can be no reasonable doubt but that he murdered Mr. Schulte. We first find Buchholz and Schulte at the Sonne hotel in New York. The former servant of Schulte declares his intention of leaving, and Buchholz presses his services upon the old man for the petty sum of three dollars per month. Schulte had previously paid boys this small pittance, but when a full-grown man offers his services at such a rate, even old Mr. Schulte's economical ideas are shocked. This eagerness of Buchholz to accompany the old man, who was known to carry large sums of money upon his person, shows a deep and well-laid plan to accomplish this murder. The strongest evidence that the state offers consists of the exhibits, the watch, the money, the clothes, the hair brush belonging to Buchholz, the old rag with blood spots upon it; the Waring axe and the pocketbook containing Schulte's bills, which Stark recovered by means of Buchholz's statements. What does the state offer? The tramp theory. It would be stronger if one of the witnesses for the defense had not stated that he counted 250 tramps pass by his house in two days; the tramp law was not then in existence.
The testimony of young Eli Savage was thought to be unworthy of credence. The manner of the boy upon the stand showed he was an imaginative person. He may have seen tramps that day but the details are afterthoughts. Why did he keep this story he now tells, hid in his breast so long; the only reason he can give is that he was afraid of the cross-examination. According to the figures of the defense Buchholz should have arrived at the Waring house at 6:49 o'clock on the evening of the murder, but according to the Waring's he did not arrive until seven. He was eleven minutes over due. This gave him ample time for the commission of the deed. The murder required only two blows and the money was hid in the barn in a short space of time. It is true, urged the lawyer in closing, that the prisoner is a stranger in a strange land and is entitled to sympathy, but the old man who was murdered was also a stranger here, and he must not be forgotten and justice must be done his murderer.
MR. BOLLMAN'S ARGUMENT.
Mr. Charles Bollman of New Haven, began the arguments for the defense. During his entire argument Buchholz sobbed and wept bitterly. Realizing the magnitude of the task before him he almost shrank from the performance of his duty. He rose with feelings of both pain and joy. He was joyful to think the verdict of the jury was about to remove from the young man who occupied the prisoner's seat the name of murderer which the gentleman who had just closed had ascribed to him without waiting for the verdict which shall either acquit or condemn him. I cannot but feel, continued Mr. Bollman, that you must and will acquit this young [man] who is charged with this terrible crime, but alas, even with such a verdict he cannot be released from imprisonment for many years to come.
Mr. Bollman said that if any credit was due to the defense in this case nine-tenths, yes ninety-nine one hundredths of it was due to his associate, General Smith. He spoke of the liability of tribunals to err and said the law wisely provided that juries must acquit unless they are satisfied beyond every reasonable doubt of the prisoner's guilt. The case was one of those involving circumstantial evidence, which is aptly compared to a chain. If one of the links is missing the chain falls to the ground; if one circumstance is inconsistent with the case of the state the jury must acquit. If some of the circumstances necessary to prove the case are not only consistent with the theory of the state but are also consistent with some other theory by which the innocence of the prisoner is established, the jury must acquit.
The lawyer dwelt at length upon verdicts in the first or second degree, and then passed to a review of the testimony. The state occupied three weeks to prove its case and produced sixty witnesses. Pinkerton, of New York, Dr. Treadwell, of Boston, whose very necktie speaks blood, home made detectives, and representatives of the German empire have all been here; the jail has been partly emptied that Buchholz may be proved guilty of murder. What has been proved? Simply that the prisoner had some of his master's money after the murder. Nothing more. Mr. Lane and other witnesses testify that the body was searched while it was being carried to the second stone wall. The state now admits that this gave Buchholz an opportunity to remove one of the pocketbooks. Sam Waring remembers nothing about two pocketbooks near the body of Schulte, but at the former trial when his memory was fresh he testified that he saw them. One of them we think was the one that Stark found in the Waring barn. The jury has heard the three different statements of Dr. Pardee regarding the wounds upon Schulte's head. In every murder case a correct knowledge of the nature of the fatal wounds is all important. Why did not the state have a different doctor, one who could have accurately explained the wounds and given the jury some idea of them? The body of Schulte was sent back to Germany within a day or two of the murder, before Buchholz had any counsel and before the wounds had been really examined. Why were the heirs of Schulte so anxious that the body should cross the ocean in such a terrible hurry? They may have had weighty reasons for their hurry. This Dr. Pardee says upon the witness stand that he tried to disremember what little he knew about the case. The notes that he once took he did not save. He says he measured the depth of the wound with his finger and guessed at the length of that finger. At the coroner's jury he testified that the wound was three inches deep.
Another witness was Stark, the detective, a man with a wonderful knowledge of human nature, and a wonderful self-control. He could make Buchholz cry at pleasure, so wonderful was his influence over him. But when he insinuated that Buchholz was the murderer, the latter said, "Oh, I cannot have the man who I am to live with always think that I am a murderer." The only thing that Stark could get from him was that he had taken the money.
OLMSTEAD'S ARGUMENT.
----------
A STRONG PLEA FOR THE STATE.
----------
Making Plain the Link in the Chain of Circumstantial Evidence – Review of the Expert Testimony – The Question of Time Again.
BRIDGEPORT, March 12. – At the opening of the court this morning, Mr. Hyde, a juror in the former trial of Buchholz, testified that while examining the hat of John H. Schulte in the jury room, he tore a little of the material at the cut which it is supposed was made by the instrument which caused the fatal wounds; he thought the piece torn off was about the size of a sixteenth of an inch.
Mr. Olmstead concluded his argument for the state to-day. Some little anxiety was caused the lawyers for the defense yesterday, by a report that the state attorney intended to take advantage of the recently passed statute giving to the state the closing argument in criminal cases. It was understood that he was waiting for an engrossed copy of the bill, before applying to the court for a change of what has been the custom in the courts of this state. The copy did not arrive, however, and the closing arguments will be made this afternoon, by General Smith, for the defense.
Mr. Olmstead began his powerful argument by an apt quotation from Daniel Webster's famous speech in a murder trial, ending with the well known words "and suicide is confession." The quotation was read with all the force and eloquence of which the attorney was capable, and produced a marked effect in the court room. Mr. Olmstead called upon God to witness the sincerity of his motives in the performance of his duty in this case, the ferreting out of the guilty parties in this cool, calculating money-making murder. The fact that no one knew when Schulte was going to return from New York was evidence that, looking upon it in the most favorable light to the prisoner, Buchholz cannot but have been a confidant in the crime. The atrocity of the murder was dwelt upon and a review of the testimony concerning the events that preceded the murder was made. The quarrel between Schulte and Buchholz, followed by the notice to the servant to quit the master's service on the 29th of the coming month, January, the buying of the revolver and the fact that Buchholz knew that the old man carried large sums of money about his person were portrayed in turn. What occurred in Hirscher’s saloon the afternoon of the murder was next touched upon. Buchholz's conversation was but introductory to the crime which he had planned. He says, "we shan't get home until dark and I have not anything to defend myself with." Then he wants to know the name of the man that had warned him against tramps. He had been annoyed by tramps. How had they annoyed him? Why they asked him for tobacco. A great annoyance! He wanted to be able to say to Hirscher afterwards "didn't I tell you I was afraid I would be attacked." But he spent some time that afternoon with Pitzer's little ones. It is not the first time that a man who is planning a terrible crime has attempted to allay suspicion by playing with children before the commission of the deed. We have had a case just like it in this very court room. When Buchholz arrived at the house after the murder he said, "let us go down to the woods, I am no afraid." It is not strange knowing what he did that he was "no afraid." But Sammy Waring's brother was and so they went first to the neighbors. When Starke asked Buchholz why he didn't make a more serious wound on his face Buchholz was confused and dumbfounded. The scratch did not amount to anything and might have been made by the bushes. The defense claims that the wounds on Schulte's head could not have been made by the axe. But if any member of the jury believes that Buchholz was connected with the case he must remember that the state is not compelled to rely on the axe; that is not of the least consequence in the case. Dr. Treadwell, a man with a long experience as a surgeon, says he has frequently known of cases where clean cuts have been made with a blunt instrument. The defense have had two young doctors on the stand. One has had five years' experience. They put at naught the opinions of such a man as Dr. Sanford. Their zeal, as giving promise of future eminence, is commendable. But we have what is better than the testimony of the surgeons, the testimony of William Buchholz himself. In his communications to detective Stark, he says the murder was committed with an axe; then he recovered himself and said at least they said it was an axe at the coroner's jury. This admission, made in an unguarded moment, is all important. Whether the corpuscles were burned off by the fire or ground off by Dingee's grindstone, the probability is that this axe, or at least another one like it, was used in this murder. Blood was seen on this axe the morning after the murder by many. Some of the witnesses saw a feather upon it. There were feathers lying upon the ground, and how easy it would have been for Buchholz to stick a feather upon it. What object did Dr. Treadwell have in coming here and testifying that he saw blood on the axe if he did not. He would have got his $250 for his analysis just the same. He has a reputation at stake, and nothing to gain by testifying falsely. Any farmer on the jury can see that the axe was not much ground, and the girl herself testifies that she got tired, and that the grinding lasted only a few moments. Then there is another point. Who knows but that the new handle was put in before the murder? Sam Waring thinks the grinding was about a month after the murder, but how easy it is for any one to be mistaken in such a matter. His sister comes upon the stand to correct one mistake she has made, showing that she was not certain in her testimony. Dr. Treadwell testifies that he found no blood on the old handle, but he did find human blood on the new one. This point was not pursued while the doctor was upon the stand, for the state did not then know the circumstances of the removal of the handle, but the fact remains in testimony. But there is a tangible link in the chain which cannot be contradicted. How came the blood spots on Buchholz's pants. We have shown, beyond all question, that the pantaloons examined by Dr. Treadwell were worn by Buchholz the day of the murder. It will be remembered that Gen. Smith arose when Dr. Treadwell was called, and asked that the defense be authorized to send for experts to contradict him. No objection was made; they had the state of Connecticut at their back as well as the prosecution. The spots have never been accounted for. The intimation has been made that they may have fallen upon the pants while Buchholz was assisting in carrying the body of Schulte to the Waring house. But all the witnesses agree that Buchholz had hold of the right shoulder with his right hand. How came the spots on his left side. But the blood is in the texture and their direction is upwards. There can be no doubt but that when Schulte was struck the first blow he fell on his back and the blood spurted upward. Then the rag with which the axe was found is examined, and some of the same material that was found on the axe and pants is found on it by Dr. Treadwell; what it is he don't know.
The overalls found near the scene of the murder were regarded by Mr. Olmstead of no importance. It was preposterous to suppose that any one intent on murder would have worn these overalls all day in sight of every one in South Norwalk, removed them, done them up in a paper and left them on the ground near the bed. But they had never been worn. The button-holes show there never has been any strain upon them. The fact is that the old man went on a sort of a shopping expedition to New York that day and purchased the overalls. When the body was robbed they were thrown aside as of no importance. There was no light there, and how did the tramps know what was valuable and what was worthless? Who threw the things along the pathway? According to Buchholz's story he was seventy-five feet ahead of Schulte when the old man was attacked. The men who appeared to Buchholz had no time to run back the seventy-five feet and procure the articles and throw them away. Would anyone who killed the old man go back up where Buchholz says he was and throw down the articles? It is a little too much to ask the jury to believe this. Certainly no one will ever believe they ever came back that same night, after the neighborhood was aroused, and throw down the articles; nor would they come the next day. Then the hair-brush that was found belonged to Buchholz; how did the tramps get hold of that?
Mr. Olmstead turned to a consideration of the question of time and said he would show beyond all doubt that Buchholz had ample time to commit the murder and rob the body. It was cold weather and they would naturally walk rapidly. Buchholz they say carried 28 pounds of ham. But if he was intent on committing this deed, if he saw the prize within his grasp, he would have walked on time. He gave the step and time to Schulte. Even if the time was close the fact that the deed was done within the time cannot be wipped out.
According to Hirscher's statements and those of the conductor of the 6:11 train it was 6:15 when the two left the saloon and started for home. According to to Mr. Allen it was 7:10 when Buchholz and Sam Waring arrived at his house to give the alarm. According to the figures of the defense it took 25 minutes to go from Hirscher's to the Ant hill. Say it took 10 minutes to commit the deed and that 10 minutes was spent at the Waring house and the time would be 7:10 o'clock. Suppose they left Hirscher's at 6:22 and the estimate would be as follows:
Left Hirscher's … 6:22
To the Ant Hill … 25
Committing the deed … 10
At Waring house … 10
Going to Allen's … 3
--------
7:10
But by experiment it has been shown that it took 56 seconds to go from the Warings' to Allen's, and two experiments show that the scene at the Waring house lasted less than four minutes in duration. Another estimate:
Left Hirscher's … 6:15
Going to Ant Hill … 25
Striking two blows … 2
Searching the pockets … 3
Going for hams and returning … 1
Going to house, stopping at barn … 3
At Waring's … 10
Going to Allen's … 1
---------
7:00
There would still be ten minutes left. Still another:
Left Hirscher's …. 6:22
To Ant Hill …. 25
Committing deed …. 7
At house …. 5
Going to Allen's …. 1
-------
7:00
Still ten minutes left. But according to the testimony of Mary Downey, Buchholz and Schulte, good walkers she calls them, passed there at 6:30. The calculation would then be as follows, still using the figures of the defense:
Passed Mary Downey …. 6:30
To Ant Hill …. 13
Committing the deed …. 5
To the house …. 2
In the house …. 8
To Allen's …. 2
-------
7:00
Still ten minutes to spare. Mr. Olmstead made a number or other calculations, all with a similar result. He passed to a consideration of the place where the hams were found. He said the murder was well planned and that Buchholz carried the hams to the store to corroborate the story that he was to tell. The watch was next treated of, it being urged that it had been shown that it might have lain out under the sun for several months without tarnishing. The money of Schulte which was traced to Buchholz was regarded as overwhelming proof of his guilt.
THE BUCHHOLZ DEFENSE.
----------
GEN. SMITH'S POWERFUL ARGUMENT
----------
Comparing Circumstantial Evidence to a Puzzle – Why Blood Corpuscles Were Dragged Into the Case – Hard Raps at State Attorney Olmstead – The Court Adjourns Until Monday – A Disagreement Looked For.
BRIDGEPORT, March 13. – It was after three o'clock yesterday afternoon when State Attorney Olmstead finished his argument to the jury. He had made a most forcible presentation of the way in which the prosecution has looked at the case; one that was crammed full of facts from the opening to the close and without much attempt at high flown oratory or appeals to the passions of his hearers. It was an exhaustive review of the evidence to substantiate his claim that without the testimony of Stark, the detective, the jury must believe that Buchholz was the murderer of John H. Schulte; without it the chain was undoubtedly complete, the evidence overwhelming.
Had a vote been taken in the large audience at the close of Mr. Olmstead's argument, there is no doubt but a large majority would have said "guilty of murder in the first degree."
After an interval of a few moments, Gen. Smith began his argument for the defense. He spoke all the remainder of the afternoon – about two hours and a half – and concluded this morning.
Many in the court room have occupied the time while the arguments are being delivered to watch Buchholz's face. In this county, in a capital case, the prisoner is allowed to sit with his counsel and assist them by his suggestions during the taking of testimony. But Buchholz is compelled to sit in the dock, away from the lawyers. Not the least trying part of his position is the fact that he faces the entire audience. If he would hide his tears from the spectators he must put his head down on the rail in front of him. While Olmstead is hurling his invectives upon the murderer of Schulte, he sits with compressed lips, and keeps back the tears with difficulty. When Bollman speaks of his friendship for the prisoner and Gen. Smith tells the jury how hard he and his associates have labored for their client his eyelids tremble and he soon breaks down completely. "He is to be pitied anyway," say the ladies and there are many other moist eyes in the court room.
Gen. Smith has a peculiar way of talking to the jury. Part of the time he sits upon the table in front of him while he talks with his hands in his pocket. He is either chewing tobacco or sucking oranges and lemons. At the last trial his display of colored shirts was a feature of the case; it was said that he had a different shirt for every day. The present trial has been longer, and he has gone through his stock at least twice. It is said that he knows the jury thoroughly. It is certain that his familiar way of talking to them about the case has made a good impression. He began by interesting them in the defense by detailing the troubles which he and Mr. Bollman encountered in their work, not the least of which was the fact that Buchholz lied to them about taking Schulte's money.
Gen. Smith said: I regret that my opportunities have not been such as to permit me to arrange in regular sequence the ideas I have to present to you. I have only a plain honest talk and only ask your patient attention. But in considering this case you should carefully weigh the opportunities the two sides have had in preparing their respective cases. On the one side has been utilized the criminal machinery of the state. Yes, the German empire has furnished its aid through its consul general. There has been the state attorney Olmstead, Stark the detective, great and small paid agents of all grades and a host of attendants; also the Bridgeport jail. On the other side we have had William Buchholz in jail. True he has had counsel such as they are. Mr. Taylor says the state has been a wall about Buchholz. The first step in the construction of this wall was constructed long ago; it was between the client and his counsel. The state of Connecticut by its constituted authorities stood between that young man and this counsel to destroy the confidence which they would naturally place in him. I knew he was lying to me but I couldn't find out how or why. I know why now. When he was lying to me I believed he was guilty. When I began his defense at the first trial I believed he was guilty. I conducted his defense without reference to him. I had to do it. I had no confidence in him. His lawyers came to that trial fooled as lawyers had never been fooled before. We were surprised that it was necessary to send us anonymous letters, that it was necessary to send us on all sorts of fool's errands, send us to dig holes in the ground. We had to go. We had to dig the holes, but we knew we were being fooled. Well, this was followed by the verdict of murder in the first degree. We had trusted that justice was to be done to all. But our hearts were downcast. We were troubled by all sorts of strange devices on the part of the prosecution. After the verdict I found there was a terrible obstinacy to be met. It seemed to be a crime to tell anything to the counsel for the defense. I couldn't understand it for a long time. I said to the people of South Norwalk: "My God, why will you conceal the facts from us? I have done many things I wouldn't otherwise but for the fact that I wanted to prove to these men that if they would believe in me I would protect them from this man, who they feared; and I have protected some of them from the man they feared would destroy them. When a man is charged with murder every act must be looked at in an unfavorable light. This does not seem just and right. The fact that the grand jury before whom the counsel for the defense could not appear indicted him should not weigh against him. The fact that the prosecution is conducted with – let us say – zeal, should not weigh against him. When Mr. Olmstead made his argument, he read from a book to show what were the duties of the prosecuting attorney. When he got through I asked him to let me look at the book. He refused and said it was not an authority. Well I will read from a book that is an authority; it is by Judge Swift, the father of Connecticut written law. This remember is an authority:
The counsel for the state should manage every criminal prosecution with the utmost coolness and fairness. He should display no marks of zeal or passion, He should not attempt to warm the feelings or prejudice the minds of the jury, by any pathetic descriptions, or artful mispresentations. He should address himself to the understanding of the triers, and by a fair investigation of the facts and an ingenious discussion of points of law open the way to the discovery of truth and justice. Such a line of conduct would reflect the highest honor on the candour and sensibility of a public officer. But when we see the prosecution of a criminal managed with a passionate vehemence, and the argument a compound of pompous declaration, and affected pathos, we detest the prosecution as a blood thirsty savage and unfeeling monster.
This is a case of circumstantial evidence and in my opinion the most remarkable of modern times; perhaps I can't judge about that. Circumstantial evidence reminds me of a puzzle, one of those dissected puzzles. You have a number of pieces or blocks of irregular sizes and shapes. The solution of the puzzle is to put them all together in proper place so as to form a square. If the square is made and two or three pieces are left over the solution is not obtained. If you put all the pieces together but it don't make a square, the puzzle is not solved. So it is with circumstantial evidence. Every link must be in the proper place, none must be left out, all must be put in the proper place, and a perfect square must be formed. Otherwise the case is not proved. I have not the shadow of a fear that the jury will bring in a verdict of murder in the first degree and will only talk about second degree, You must be convinced beyond all reasonable doubt. I believe that many men who are legally innocence [sic] have been convicted because this phrase was misunderstood, and when it is defined the definitions are generally more difficult of explanation than the words themselves. I have an abiding conviction in the innocence of William Buchholz; I can look you all in the face and say that and I will give in my perfect way my reasons. The main point upon which the state relies is the money of Schulte which was found in Buchholz possession. It is true the money was found there. Bitterly has he suffered for it. For many years he will continue to suffer for it, no one will ever know how terribly. His crime was no worst than many I have known perpetrated under forms of law by the rich on the poor. The books say that the possession of stolen money is presumptive evidence of the theft; this is true. But the fact that Buchholz stole the money does not prove that he is a murderer.
Gen. Smith read from Wells on circumstantial evidence, and Warton on American criminal law, to show that the possession of money stolen from the deceased does not necessarily involve the guilt of murder. He gave an illustration of the way he should present his case. How do you tell the way the tide runs in a river he asked, not by the magnificent stream that sweep along with life and power, but by the little driftwood the straws. He then proceeded to a consideration of some of the details. The money he gave Mrs. Warring in October he did not believe he stole from Schulte. The old man would not simply have given him notice to quit on that account. It was probably money he received from Germany. When he was at the Sonne hotel he was expecting money. It was Kreiling's advice that he went with Schulte as his servant. The fact that he did not take his clothes when he went along with the old man only shows that he wanted to look the place over before deciding whether he would stay. Probably the fact that there were two good-looking young girls there had much to do with his determination to stay. There was no bad blood between Buchholz and Schulte the day of the murder. The testimony is that when they met in Hircher's they shook hands. There was nothing ferocious in Buchholz's character. The testimony is that he was always peaceable and lived on good terms with all about him. The ambush was undoubtedly constructed for the murder of Schulte, but not by Buchholz. After the murder it was cut down to remove the evidence. My idea of the murder is that one man stood behind that ambush, which was forty feet north of the place of the murder. I am not clear what the man wanted with Buchholz. I don't think they wanted to kill him. Schulte heard a rattling of leaves before the blow was struck. He was 117 feet from the ambush. Buchholz couldn't have followed him 117 feet without the old man's having missed him. But the blow which killed the old man could not have been struck from the ambush. It was a remarkable piece of forethought on Buchholz's part to have taken that piece of his shirt and left it on the ground two months before the murder. This they find that he wiped the axe on. Singular that he left his card there. As a matter of fact however, I am told the cloth found was of cotton, and that Buchholz's shirts are of linen. There is nothing to show that this piece of cloth came from his shirt. Dr. Treadwell found something on it he could not understand. My God gentlemen, if men are to be hung on what he don't understand none of us are safe. Why this is as flimsy as the case for the prosecution in other respects – and as ragged as dirty (throwing the rag upon the floor).
Two days after the murder they find indicia of Buchholz in the woods. They were not found the first day. Hundreds of persons searched the ground as with a fine tooth comb but they found nothing. They found the keys, the pistol and the box of nails. They find a brush which belonged to Buchholz. They were close to a stone wall where Buchholz could not have thrown them in his rapid flight. Why did Buchholz take this old antiquated pistol when he had a better one of his own. Why did he take the box of nails when he knew they were valueless and that they were easy of identification? Why did he take these and leave $20,000 on the old man’s person. I think that the murderers took the box thinking it was cash and threw it away when they found out its worthlessness. Buchholz knew where Schulte carried his money. Grüeuwald knew where it was carried. Buchholz had an opportunity, according to the state, to take it all, but he left $20,000 and took these worthless articles; put this in the puzzle if you can. I don't see why he should have placed his hair bush under the roots of a tree. I don't see how he got time to do that. When Mr. Berger took Buchholz's pants away Saturday night he placed that brush there in my opinion. Berger, Illing and Hirscher were busy manufacturing evidence. I don't accuse them of complicity in the murder, but they did wrong. You saw Hirscher faint on the witness stand. I think I know why. Illing is a German and appeared at neither trial. Berger didn't appear. I should like to have had an opportunity to ask them a few questions of these self constituted detectives. I have not the least doubt but that Berger took the things from Schulte's effects. In no other way can the piece be put into the puzzle. The one put them there who committed the murder. Buchholz held on to the carpet-bag and carried it to the Waring house because in his fright he had no thought of throwing it down. This is a speck that shows which way the wind blows. It first led men think of Buchholz's story. This shallow-pated German did not have forethought enough to know that this incident would be important, but it was worth much more than the microscopic evidence of Dr. Treadwell.
If Buchholz made those scratches on his face himself, why didn't he make the wounds more serious? Stark asked that question of Buchholz in the jail, and Buchholz he says looked bewildered, as he always did when accused of the murder. They may have been made by the telegraph wires that the Savage boy saw in the hands of the man with the piercing black eyes. You should bear in mind, in considering this case, that the statements of Buchholz, which have been read to you, are not his words or ideas given before the coroner's jury. He answered "yes" and "no" to the questions of the astute state attorney through an interpreter. The statements read were utterly deceptive.
I don't know why the watch of Mr. Schulte should have been taken as part of the desirable plunder. If Buchholz took it, why didn't he put it with the pocketbooks? Why should he drop it at the side of the path? He never dropped it there. The day after the murder hundreds of people, attracted by curiosity, passed along the path, but they didn't find it. The watch experts say it could have lain for months under the snow and not have been tarnished. When it was taken up it went all right. The watch experts are as bad as the blood experts. They give their opinions on matters they know nothing about. This is the testimony you are asked to hang a man upon. Bristling with improbabilities and impossibilities is the story of this watch.
There is the axe, another important piece in the puzzle of the state. The day after the murder many looked at it but it was rejected as of no importance in the case. One man, Arnold, says it was two-thirds covered with blood. He is contradicted by every other witness that went on to the stand. If the blood was wiped off how is it that the chicken blood remained. Dr. Treadwell finds mammalian blood – Mr. Olmstead calls it "ma-million" blood because, I suppose, he thinks there is millions in it – and that the grinding didn't destroy them. New Haven county had corpuscles and why shouldn't Fairfield county. But Fairfield county is ahead because she had her's cooled. I saw in the papers during the elaborate investigation at New Haven that the state attorney of Fairfield county was there one day enjoying the society of corpuscles and the experts. The chicken blood got upon the axe two days before the murder, but fourteen months after the all-seeing eye of Dr. Treadwell could tell which had been on the longest because the chicken blood was the most rusted. Dr. Treadwell is simply an ignoramus. He is the last man in the world to claim to be a man of science. When he found the axe had been roasted Mr. Olmstead sent word to him that he must defend himself. So he comes here with the story of this single experiment. Every one knows who examined the axe that the temper has been taken out of it. The large dent is not a dent; it has been turned like a piece of tin. If he had been a man he would have said that his corpuscles must have got on afterward and he might have got another job in this state; as it is I don't think he will. But he insists that the corpuscles survived circumstances which it would seem would have been discouraging to the most robust corpuscle. Dr. Sanford thought the irregularities in the cut in the hat corresponded to the dents in the edge of the axe. Nice kind of stuff this is to ask you to hang a man on. The axe had been used to chop wood with seven months before it was examined besides being ground.
The testimony regarding the wound was next treated of, the claim being that according to the statement of the doctor the axe could not have inflicted it. He said it might be thought strange that the defense did not put William Buchholz on the stand, but the reason was plain. He had once deceived his own lawyers and his professional pride would not permit him to place the prisoner on the stand now. Then the jury could not be expected to believe but that he would say anything to save himself from the gallows, and on the cross-examination he might state something that would tell against him even if he is innocent. Gen. Smith read what purported to be a statement by Buchholz as to how he robbed Schulte after the murder.
An elaborate review of the case followed. Gen. Smith claimed the murder was the work of hired assassins who came over from Germany. Abel, the man who came over in November and went back in May after the watch was found, was the engineer of the job. The men were told that the old man carried his money in a yellow pocketbook in his inside vest pocket. This they procured. There is testimony there was another pocketbook that has never been accounted for. This is the only explanation of the fact that twenty thousand dollars was left behind. Able, though in Norwalk during the entire inquest did not attend it although a countryman of his had been murdered; he came from the same part of Germany as did Schulte. The Savage boy's story was thought too truthful, and the only way that his and other's testimony regarding the overalls and the mysterious strangers in Norwalk the day of the murder can be explained is by the theory of the defense.
At 12:15 a.m. [surely must be p.m.] General Smith closed his argument. It was a very effective one. Its general outline only is given above; much that related to points in the evidence, the time, Schulte's characteristics and fear of being murdered, etc., is necessarily omitted.
To the surprise of most of those in the court Chief Justice Park then ordered the court adjourned until 10 a.m. Monday. He warned the jury not to converse with any one regarding the [case] during the interim. A disagreement of the jury is very generally predicted.
THE BUCHHOLZ TRIAL.
----------
CHIEF JUSTICE PARK'S CHARGE.
----------
A Review to the Jury of the Law and Facts in the Case – Request of the Defense to Charge Complied With.
BRIDGEPORT, March 15. – The superior court room was crowded to overflowing this morning, when Sheriff Sanford called the court to order. Judge Sanford occupied a seat with Chief Justice Park and Judge Loomis.
State Attorney Olmstead asked the court to charge the jury, that the imaginary statement read by General Smith in his argument, which was supposed to have come from William Buchholz, the prisoner, was improper, and ought to have no affect in the deliberations in the jury room; and that all comments made by the General as to the reasons why the prisoner did not take the stand, were not in accordance with the common law, and should receive no consideration.
Chief Justice Park then charged the jury. We are again approaching the end of this protracted trial, he began, and then proceeded to briefly review the claims of the public prosecutor. The jury must come to a consideration of the case without prejudice; this is no place for revenge and no place for mercy. Another part of the government is the place to appeal for mercy and compassion, and these qualities have no right to come here and affect the performance of the duty of the jury. The law is solicitous for the innocent and equally solicitous for the living, to protect them from assassination and all crime. There is to be nothing to interfere with the conviction of the guilty. This is a solemn duty you have to perform, solemn at all times to sit in judgment at the bar, solemn when the prisoner may be sent to confinement for a term of years, and especially solemn when the question of his life is in your hands, solemn to the county whose protectors you are, solemn to the friends and relatives of the deceased, and solemn to the prisoner at the bar. Thus far the court has the satisfaction of knowing that justice has been done.
The grand jury has brought in a true bill for murder in the first degree against this prisoner. He has been put to plea upon the charge of the commission of this terrible crime. The killing of one person by another is called homicide. Homicide is divided into justifiable, excusable and felonious. It is only necessary to speak of the latter kind. It is divided into manslaughter and murder. To prove that the crime is one of murder the element of "malice aforethought" must be shown, and this is applicable to both degrees of murder. Under the common law both degrees are regarded as of equal enormity. But now, by statute, the jury may find the prisoner guilty of murder in a lesser degree than that charged in the indictment. Murder in the first degree requires more deliberation, more forethought than in the second degree. The statute provides that all murder by poison shall be murder in the first degree. It is easy to see that murder cannot be committed in that way without mature deliberation. Murder by lying in wait is also murder in the first degree. It is also easy to see that murder cannot be committed in that way without deliberate reflection. So in the other kinds of murder in the first degree expressed malice is generally shown. Implied malice holds the party guilty of murder in the second degree, as where one in attempting to kill another kills a friend whom he did not intend to kill, or where a party discharges a loaded gun into a crowd, or throws from a high building some heavy substance and one is killed. These are cases where the law implies malice, although no expressed malice is shown. We are dealing with a case where it is said a willful murder was committed for the purpose of robbery. If this be true it would seem that the case was one of murder in the first degree, but if the evidence warrants it you may return a verdict of murder in the second degree or manslaughter. Another statute provides that no person shall be convicted of murder in the first degree without the testimony of two witnesses or what is its equivalent. The claim of the defendant is that this statute means that the testimony of the witnesses for the state must be equivalent to the testimony of two witnesses swearing that they saw the murder committed. But the court does not so construe the statute. Such a construction would not permit of the application of the statute to a case where the testimony is circumstantial. No rule as to the weighing of the testimony can be given; what criterion can be found in the selection of the evidence which is to be taken as equal to that of two witnesses who swear directly to the fact? Such a construction would require absolute certainty, something that can never be shown. The construction which the court puts upon the statute is as follows: By the ancient common law the testimony of one person was sufficient to convict any person of any crime except perjury, provided that his testimony was sufficient to prove the commission of the crime beyond all reasonable doubt.
But this statute changes the common law as far as capital cases are concerned. The danger that the one witness, no matter how honest or how competent to testify, may be mistaken, caused the legislature to make necessary the testimony of two witnesses in capital cases. But this requirement does not extend to murder in the second degree, so that if the jury think that the commission of the crime has not been shown by the testimony of two witnesses or its equivalent, they should return a verdict of murder in the second degree.
The chief justice turned to a consideration of the case on trial. He said that in the law it made no difference as to the guilt of the accused whether he was alone in the commission of the deed or had a confederate. A case of circumstantial evidence tried in New Haven county was alluded to. Here the main evidence was a piece of steel that was found in the murdered man's skull and which fitted a nick in the knife of the accused. An extract from Wharton on criminal law was read to the jury to show that cases of conviction of innocent men which may be read to the juries should not frighten them from rendering a verdict of guilty.
At the request of the defense a number of charges were made: That juries were the judges of the law and the fact. It is the province of the court to state its opinion on points of law and then submit both to the jury without any direction as to how the verdict shall be formed. Every man is presumed to be innocent until proved guilty. The burden of proof is upon the state. It is necessary for the state to make out a case of probable guilt and then call upon the prisoner to disprove it. In every case a good and sufficient indictment setting forth with certainty what it is proposed to prove is required. The name of the deceased is a material point. A mistake in the spelling is not material provided the sound of the name as given in the indictment is not different from that under which the deceased was known during his life. The deceased must be so described that there will be no possibility of mistaking him for any one else. The state claims that Johan in German is the same as John in English. If you find that the name in the indictment is the English of the name of the deceased, and that it was impossible to mistake him for any one else, there is no variance between the proof and the indictment. The facts used in an endeavor to show the innocence of the accused need not be as conclusive as those used in showing his guilt. By reasonable or rational doubt is meant when there is something that prevents an abiding conviction. It does not mean absolute certainty, nor an imaginary doubt. It means a doubt that the party entertaining it can give. The jury should be cautious from drawing inferences from statements supposed to have been made by the accused, as the offering here and there of a word or two by the party to whom the statements are said to have been made, may have materially altered the construction to have been placed upon them. If the admissions were voluntarily made and clearly proved, they are oftentimes the most satisfactory of proof. Witnesses who testify after having been paid for obtaining the admissions, do not stand on the same footing as to credence, as ordinary citizens who testify to facts that happen naturally under their observation. The evidence of convicts is to be taken with great caution. The fact that the prisoner does not himself testify in the case, is not to be taken as an inference that he is guilty. No one can be compelled to testify against themselves.
Yesterday’s Third Edition
THE BUCHHOLZ TRIAL.
----------
Conclusion of Judge Park's Charge to the Jury.
It is claimed that Buchholz was among those who knew that Schulte carried large amounts of money in his possession. He knew that he went to New York, and what train he was coming back upon. It is claimed that he was seldom out after dark, and that he was seldom away from home. He had about $70,000 upon his person the day of the murder. More than $50,000 of it was subsequently found to have been in the possession of the accused immediately after the murder. Some $20,000 was found upon the ground near the body. It is evident that the motive in the case was not malice, it was gain, and we should naturally expect that whoever did the horrible deed at all events got what he did the deed for. And who had the treasure afterward?
It is said that some $18,200 in bills with Schulte's mark upon them were traced to the accused. It is claimed by the defense that the money was given to him by Schulte on the night of the murder. That the prisoner had given him the money to keep when he first entered his employ. The state claims it was absurd that the deceased should have given the accused the money while on the way home in a dark night when he had only to wait a few minutes and both would have been home.
General Smith interrupted to say that the defense made no such claim. They admitted that Buchholz made such statements to the coroner's jury but he was not telling the truth. The defense made no such absurd claim.
Judge Park then advanced the claim of the defense as to how Buchholz came into possession of the money when carrying the body from the woods, and said that the state claims this to have been impossible. The public prosecutor claims that it is improbable that the accused went away after the murder, leaving that large sum of money which could have been found in a moment, and then return. "Go away," repeated the judge, "leaving that large sum of money – seventy thousand dollars – and then return," said Judge Park slowly.
The prisoner has confessed to taking the money to Stark, but did not tell the detective – his best friend as he considered him – how he got it. But would he, knowing that he was suspected of murder, have told how he got it, if he was guilty of the murder. The defense claim that he did not act like a murderer. When he was going to the depot he wanted Mrs Waring to go, and did not have murder in his heart then, think the defense. The state think that if Mr. Schulte had come up from New York on that day he would not have been murdered.
The judge referred to many other points in the testimony in most cases giving the strong points of the state. It was thought to be nothing against Abel that he stopped in a hotel a few days.
Chief Justice Park talked about two hours and a quarter. He concluded at one o'clock and a recess was taken for dinner until 2 p. m. The jury then retired and ate dinner in the court room.
The charge is generally regarded as strongly against the accused.
The lawyers for the defense think the charge not nearly so severe against their client as at the former trial. Then, they say, the claims of the defense were not even alluded to, while in the charge to-day they were referred to at length. It is regarded as strange that not a word was said about the expert testimony by the judge.
To-day for the first time during the trial Buchholz was taken back to the jail for dinner. Previously he has eaten dinner at a restaurant under the charge of sheriffs, but to-day they refused to take the responsibility and Jailor Wells took him.
The Bridgeport young lady who is said to have fallen in love with Buchholz, has been in court during every day of the trial. She brings her dinner and stays during the noon recess. Saturday the prisoner was presented with a handsome bouquet by a German lady.
Up to the time of writing this afternoon – 3 o'clock – nothing has been heard from the jury. The judges have not yet appeared; neither has the prisoner. The court room habitues are predicting a disagreement.
Second Edition
WAITING FOR A VERDICT.
----------
THE JURY OUT 24 HOURS ALREADY.
----------
Gossip in the Buchholz Court Room – The Jurors Sleep Over Night in Chairs – The Hoyt Case to be Argued To-morrow.
BRIDGEPORT, March 16. – William Buchholz was brought down from the jail this morning and court was then opened. His appearance had not changed materially. If anything he was better looking and more "slick" than usual. His hair was carefully combed, his face cleanly shaven and his new suit of dark clothes had been brushed as though by a professional valet.
The jury did not call for their breakfast until quite late; quite likely the night they had passed was not of a character to give them very strong appetites. The room in which they have been confined since one o'clock yesterday afternoon is about 12x16 feet. The furniture consist of two tables and a dozen chairs. If the jury wants anything it is called for, and the court officers get it for them. Thus far their demands have been limited to three meals and Mr. Bollman's map of the route followed by John H. Schulte and the prisoner on the night of the murder in South Norwalk. The former were supplied from a restaurant, but Judge Park refused them the map on the ground that it was not an exhibit, and it had not been sworn to during the trial. Why the jury preferred to go without mattresses and sleep last night in chairs is not known. The deputy sheriffs think it was because they expected, up to midnight, to come to an agreement. It is known that they did not end their deliberations and discussions until that hour. Had they then called for beds the court officers would have been unable to supply them.
This morning at nine o'clock the court bench was occupied by Judges Park, Loomis, Carpenter, Pardee and Granger, the judges of the supreme court, and the March term for Fairfield county was begun. The supreme court was adjourned to the common pleas court room down stairs. Here a remnant of the spectators who had waited patiently for a verdict, until the adjournment of the court at ten o'clock last evening repaired. The seats for spectators will hold fifty persons and were sufficient to accommodate the session of the court, if session it may be called, when the judges were up stairs hearing a civil case in another court, the jury was locked up in another part of the building, and neither the state attorney, the lawyers for the defense nor the prisoner were present. During the morning Buchholz was given the liberty of the bar library, and under the surveillance of Sheriff Sanford proceeded to and fro, gazed out of the windows on to State street, or listening with some show of interest to the technical arguments in the case of J. Wilbur Parrott vs. Housatonic Railroad company. At one o'clock to-day the jury had been out just twenty-four hours, and nothing had been heard from them as to the possibility or impossibility of arriving at an agreement. At the last trial when the jury finally reported a verdict of murder in the first degree, they were out eighteen hours.
Among those who have taken great interest in the case has been Mrs. P. T. Barnum. She sat out the long session of waiting yesterday afternoon and evening, and was one of the first to apply for admission at the court room doors at eight o'clock this morning. P. T. Barnum also looked into the court room for a few minutes this morning. The ladies of Bridgeport, or at least many of them have shown more interest in the case than the men. Many have been regular attendants upon the court, bringing their dinners with them that they need not lose their seats.
The case of the state against Edwin Hoyt, a motion for a new trial, will be argued to-morrow. State Attorney Olmstead will appear for the state and H. F. Sanford and W. F. Taylor for the prisoner. Hoyt hails from Sherman, and in February, 1879, was tried for killing his father, George Hoyt, by stabbing him with a butcher knife. He was convicted of murder in the first degree and sentenced to be hung May 13, 1880. There are some novel points to be argued and the case will be an interesting one. Errors in the admission of evidence is claimed and also errors in the admission of jurors.
THE JURY STILL OUT.
----------
A DISAGREEMENT REPORTED.
----------
The Buchholz Jury Tired After Their Confinement of Forty Hours and Want to be Discharged – They are Charged Again and Sent Back Until this Afternoon – A Lively Scene in Court.
BRIDGEPORT, March 17. – The Buchholz jury were given the freedom of the court room last night, and slept there under the surveillance of a deputy sheriff. Two sofas were brought into the room and a supply of blankets. Their long confinement has evidently worn them out, and at half-past seven o'clock they sent word to the judges that they wished to come out and make a report. Judges Park and Loomis were sent for, and opened court at half-past eight. The jurors filed into the court room. Both their faces and clothes showed the result of their imprisonment for forty hours and more.
"Have you agreed upon a verdict?" was the stereotyped question of the clerk.
Foreman Gregory said: "We have not." It seemed to the breathless auditors that he made a long pause between the words "have" and "'not."
Chief Justice Park – "Is there any probability of your coming to an agreement?"
Foreman Gregory – "No, I am certain there is no possibility."
Chief Justice Park – "Are there any questions upon which the court can enlighten the jury?"
There was no response.
Chief Justice Park consulted for a moment with Judge Loomis and then asked, "Have any jurors any questions to ask?"
There was no response, and then Chief Justice Park and Judge Carpenter – who is sitting with him hearing supreme court cases – went into the bar library and remained about ten minutes.
Upon again taking the bench Chief Justice Park spoke in substance as follows: "This case is one of great importance, and has occupied the time of the court for four weeks. It is probable that every detail in connection with the case that can be known has been brought out. Another jury would be compelled to decide upon the same facts that have been brought before you. It is of the greatest importance that if possible an agreement be arrived at. The case is one that demands immediate decision, and if another trial is necessary it must be had at once. There is perhaps one point that I did not speak upon as fully as I should have done the other day. That is the question of time. The question is whether the prisoner had time to do the deed. Of course, if he did not have time he could not have done it. The public prosecutor claims that if every detail was arranged beforehand by the accused, if the ambush was prepared, if the axe or hatchet or other weapon whatever it may have been was on hand, if everything down to the smallest detail was prepared beforehand it could not have taken to exceed fifteen seconds to commit the deed. It is claimed that he darted out from the ambush, struck the fatal blow; it would not have taken, if he had deliberately planned the murder, over fifteen seconds. The rifling of the pockets to one who was familiar with the places where the amount of money exceeding $70,000 was kept, as was this accused, the whole deed could have been committed in two minutes. As to the hiding of the pocketbooks the evidence is that they were simply thrown under the straw. This act was not immediate. The further concealment was deferred until a more convenient season. As to the time of the train which arrived at South Norwalk it probably left there at 6:11. As the time for stopping was about two minutes it probably arrived at 6:09. The testimony is that Mr. Schulte drank beer in a saloon near the depot and ordered some more. Upon the time it would take to drink a glass of beer, it would depend whether the man was in a hurry, and upon the state of mind he was in. This was the first time this man, since his coming to Norwalk, had ever been out after dark. Here it was two hours after sundown. He had to exceed $70,000 in his possession, and he must have been uneasy in his mind. The Warings had no clock. They knew the time of passing trains – that is, about the time. There was a train that arrived about 6:45 –”
Mr. Olmstead – "The time was 6:48; this is not disputed."
Chief-Justice Park – "Yes; about 6:48. Shortly after this train passed, the accused arrived at the house. A few movements were gone through with, and then they went to the Allens', arriving there about 7:10. The conductor of the 6:48 train says there was nothing to cause him to note whether the train was late or not. He only knows that when he arrived at New Haven there was nothing to cause him to note that he was late at any intermediate station, and this point (New Haven) is eighteen miles from the scene of the murder."
Mr. Olmstead – "Not eighteen, but thirty."
Chief-Justice Park – "Yes, thirty. It is possible that the train was two or three minutes late. The down train (6:24) has been testified to, but there was nothing to cause the conductor to note whether it was late or not. It may have been two or three minutes late at South Norwalk. The question of time is all uncertain. The defense has urged with great earnestness that the murderer could not have committed the deed in the time. If the question was about half of an hour or an hour it might have been of great importance; but when it is only two or three moments, it is not."
When the chief justice finished Foreman Gregory placed his hands down on the arms of his chair as if about to rise but Juror White, who had been busy taking notes during the judge's remarks, reached over, touched him on the shoulder and shook his head, looking toward the jury room.
Chief Justice Park – "Has any juror any questions to ask?"
Juror Morehouse – "What reliance should be placed on the testimony of Dr. Treadwell?"
After consulting with Judge Loomis, Chief Justice Park replied in substance: The question is one of fact to be decided by the jury as the credibility of any witness. Their appearance on the stand, the way they testify, whether swift to testify for one side or the other, whether they appear to endeavor to testify all they know, should be considered. The testimony was that this axe was placed in the fire to burn out the wood in the eye. They made no note of the time. One witness testifies that the handle was afterward gotten out with considerable labor, going to show that the axe might have been cold. The putting of a new handle into an axe is a very common occurrence; it is done in all families. There was nothing about it to impress it upon their minds when it was done. It might have been done before the murder. Dr. Treadwell testified that he found mammalian blood on the axe and also fowl blood, and that he could distinguish between them. Afterward he testified to an experiment to show that heat to a certain degree would not affect corpuscles of blood. But he afterwards said it was his first experiment of the kind and that he did not know of any one who had had ever performed a similar one. He said the blood on the pants was driven into the texture of the fabric. It is claimed by the state that the head being covered with blood at the time of the second blow, the head being a hard substance and the axe being a hard substance, the blood would have spattered and driven on to the pants in the way the witness found them; and that if the blood had dropped on to the pants it would have run down and not become so incorporated into the texture."
General Smith – May I be allowed to make a request in regard to this charge?"
Chief Justice Park – "We do not desire to hear any arguments. The time for arguments has passed."
Gen. Smith – "I do not desire to make any argument, but simply wish to make a request in regard to this charge. I would simply like to request that the jury be instructed that if any doubt exists upon any point, the prisoner must have the benefit of it."
THE JURY DISCHARGED.
----------
A THIRD TRIAL FOR BUCHHOLZ.
----------
Fifty-eight Ballots and Sixty-eight Hours Deliberation – The Crowd in the Court Room – Bucholz's Appearance – The Jury Largely in Favor of a Verdict of Murder in the First Degree.
BRIDGEPORT, March 18. – When Chief Justice Park ordered a recess in the Buchholz court yesterday afternoon, from two o'clock until eight, it was generally supposed that when the latter time arrived and the jury had reported that they were still unable to agree they would have been discharged from further consideration of the case. It was after eight o'clock when Judges Park and Loomis appeared upon the bench; along side of them were Judges Carpenter and Granger of the superior court. The court room was crowded as it had not been crowded since the commencement of the trial. State Attorney Olmstead had taken an early train home, and this was regarded by the knowing ones of the court room as a sure indication that there would be no change in the situation that night. All sorts of rumors prevailed about the court room. It was said that the jury would not be discharged at that time of night, because all of them being farmers and living away from the railroads, they could not reach their homes before the next day, and they might just as well remain in the court room another night. There was a surprising lack of rumors as to how the jury stood; in the Hayden case at New Haven, every one that was any one at all thought they knew just how the jury stood, but here all were at sea. It was reported that at New Haven it was rumored that the jury stood 7 to 5 – 7 for acquittal to 5 for second degree – but the foundation for the rumor was wanting.
Shortly after eight o'clock a deputy sheriff was sent into the jury-room by the court. He returned and reported that they had nothing to report. An adjournment was then ordered until 8 a. m. to-day. Almost every one in the court room laughed or smiled. Buchholz was the exception. His eyes filled with tears. He did not have time to dwell over his disappointment; Jailor Wells hurried him off to the jail.
When the court came in this morning the expected discharge of the jury took place. It was evident to all parties, court, lawyers and spectators, that nothing was to be gained by keeping them longer in confinement; if they could not agree after a consultation of sixty-eight hours, there was very little hope of their ever becoming of one mind.
State Attorney Olmstead made an immediate motion for a speedy new trial. He asked that the third trial of the case be set down for April 13. The court granted the request, notwithstanding the efforts of Gen. Smith to secure a longer delay. The general urged that he was worn out after the laborious duties of the present trial, and needed a longer period for recuperation. He doubted whether his health, not at any time robust, could stand so immediate another protracted siege. Then again he was upon the trace of what he believed was new evidence and important evidence for the defense; time was needed to investigate it. Besides all this he had other business which he had neglected for this case; it had accumulated during the trial and was now pressing upon him.
Mr. Olmstead gave as one reason why he desired an immediate trial that one of the important witnesses for the state was anxious to go to South America. A protracted delay would prevent his appearance in the court. It is supposed he referred to Stark, the detective.
General Smith said in reply, that he would be willing to agree to the admission of the stenographic report of the witness' testimony, but Mr. Olmstead declined to accept the proposition.
So the date of the third trial was fixed at April 13.
The nearest that the jury came to an agreement was yesterday, after Chief Justice Park's supplemental charge. Then they stood nine to three – nine for murder in the first degree, two for second degree, and one for acquittal. It was in fact another case of eleven obstinate jurors. Before Judge Park's second charge, the ballots in the jury room were of great variety; at one time the twelve stood six to six, half of them being in favor of hanging, and half voting for acquittal.
As was to have been expected neither side, the state represented by Mr. Olmstead, nor the defense represented by Messrs. Smith, Bollman and Austin, are satisfied with the result. General Smith says that he does not feel confident that he will be able to go on with the case. The law demands of his other business are so pressing that he does not see how he can devote another month to a third trial.
Buchholz manifested little emotion when the discharge of the jury took place. He was evidently expecting the result. He is said to be utterly without means now; the legacy of $2,500 which he received from Germany is exhausted, and he has nothing to pay his lawyers for another trial. If they work for him again it will be on principle or for love.
What the new evidence is that Buchholz's lawyers claim to be on the track of is a matter of conjecture, but it is reported that the mysterious visit of a German to Bridgeport, soon after the murder, has something to do with it. The story goes that he tried to find the first selectman of the city, saying he had something important to tell him about Mr. Schulte's death. The first selectman was not found, but the stranger dropped the intimation that Schulte was killed by hired assassins from Germany.
The REGISTER saw fit a few days since to criticize the course of Chief Justice Park in writing a letter requesting the reprieve of Hamlin, the murderer of Wells Shipman. The due administration of justice was liable to be brought into disrepute by the postponement of Hamlin's execution, when there was no possible excuse or reason for such delay. It is, therefore, with special pleasure that the REGISTER feels at liberty to commend Chief Justice Park his resolute course in the Buchholz case now on trial at Bridgeport. The judge evidently realizes that there is more than the mere question of the prisoner's guilt or innocence on trial in the case. The jury system itself is on trial. If the laws of the state are so deficient that a jury cannot find a verdict in the Buchholz case, there is clearly a necessity for a reformation in the laws. The prisoner was tried once and convicted of murder in the first degree. Because a foolish juror talked too freely the verdict was we think needlessly, set aside and a new trial awarded. No new evidence of any importance was presented by the prisoner at the present trial. It was shown that there were several persons in Norwalk the day of the murder, resembling genteel tramps, but the crime was not fastened upon any one of them. The money belonging to the murdered man was found in the prisoner's possession. There was no reasonable doubt of the prisoner's guilt. Yet a jury has been deliberating upon the question of his guilt since last Monday, and at the present writing has not been able to agree. Such a state of affairs is scandalous and, though the jury wanted to be discharged several days ago for professed inability to agree, the judge resolutely refused to grant that request. The judge has made every constant effort to enable the jury to render a verdict and a true verdict, but thus far in vain. If the jury disagrees, as is likely, we trust that Judge Park will do as he intimated a day or two ago and proceed with the third trial of the case at the very earliest day possible.
EVENTS OF THE DAY.
The Buchholz jury, after being out sixty eight hours and after taking fifty-eight ballots, disagreed and was discharged by the court. The case is set down for trial the third time on April 13th. The jury is reported to have stood, when discharged, nine for murder in the first degree, two for murder in the second degree, and one for acquittal. It is little less than a public calamity that the jury did not agree upon a verdict, though a disagreement is better than a false verdict. The record of recent murder trials in Connecticut is peculiar. Allen's fifth trial begins shortly; Buchholz' third trial begins in a month, and Hayden's second trial is yet to be fixed. Ten trials to three murders seems to be giving the prisoners every conceivable advantage in escaping the hangman. Either a different class of jurors or a different mode of selecting jurors should be adopted. The present jury system is a clog to the wheels of justice.
Buchholz's mistake seems to have been not so much that he murdered Schulte, as that he stole a large amount of money from his bleeding body. Killing a man does not seem to impress the average Connecticut juryman as seriously as stealing. If Buchholz had poisoned or stabbed the old man to gratify his lust or malice, he would have stood a better chance with his jury, but stealing $60,000 was inexcusable.