Coverage of the third trial of William Bucholz for the murder of John H. Schulte, in the New York Sun, April and May of 1880.
The first two trials had been covered by multiple reports every day, but third trial was definitely not as well reported. As far as I can tell, the New York Sun had the most complete coverage.
Willlam Bucholz's Third Trial.
William Bucholz was put on trial for the third time yesterday, before Judge Beardsley and Associate Judge Culver, in the Criminal Part of the Superior Court, Bridgeport, for the murder of John Henry Schulte near South Norwalk, Conn., in December, 1878. The first and second trials were before Chief Justice Park and Associate Justice Loomis. At the first trial the jury convicted the prisoner, but it was shown that one of them had expressed an opinion before its close. A second trial was the result. At this trial nine of the jury were ready to convict, it is said, either of the first or of the second degree of murder. One was for acquittal. State Attorney James H Olmstead then moved for the trial which began yesterday. Associated with him is Mr Nelson Taylor. Gen Randall Smith of South Norwalk and Mr. William H. Bollman of New Haven have conducted the defense from the beginning. The prisoner looked bright and hopeful yesterday morning.
Brief Mention
The third trial of William Bucholz for the murder of John H. Schulte progressed as far as the testimony of two witnesses yesterday. Dr. M. B. Pardee of South Norwalk described the finding of the body and the nature of the wounds. Mrs. Amelia Waring, who lived in the house with Schulte, repeated the story of the miser's life and the happenings on the night of the murder.
BUCHOLZ'S THIRD TRIAL
----------
The State Resting Without Calling Either Dr. Treadwell or Hineman.
BRIDGEPORT, April 27. – The third week of the third trial of William Bucholz, for the murder of the old miser, J. H. Schulte, began this morning. This afternoon the State rested after making out substantially the same case against the prisoner as in the two previous trials. State Attorney Olmstead has presented less evidence this time, however, not having called either Dr. Treadwell, the Boston expert on blood corpuscles, or Hineman, the jailbird, who before testified to certain statements that he claimed Bucholz made to him when they were thrown together in the jail.
Dr. Treadwell testified before that over a year after the murder was committed he found human blood corpuscles on the axe taken from the Warings' barn: but subsequent witnesses destroyed whatever effect this testimony might have had by showing that immediately after the murder the axe blade was kept in the fire a long time to burn out the broken handle, and was subsequently thoroughly scoured. Hineman declared that Bucholz revealed to him the existence of $6,000 more of the old man's treasure, which he had concealed, and which had not been discovered, and partly matured a plan for effecting his escape with Hineman's assistance. As Hineman was in jail for forgery, the prisoner's counsel claimed that he had trumped up the story to better his own chances. It is doubtful whether the former jury gave the story much credence, and the State Attorney probably thought the present jury would not. With the exceptions noted, the State's case is about the same as before, although it is thought that the defence has gained some advantages for the prisoner on a number of minor points.
This morning Gen. Smith asked the consent of the court to have the jury make an excursion to the scene of the murder, the same as the Hayden jury. The State Attorney opposed the motion and it was denied. Judge Beardsley saying that the circumstances in the Hayden case differed from those in this, and that all necessary information could be obtained from maps.
Some new evidence for the defence was brought out this afternoon by Sadie Waring. She says that the night following the murder, while Bucholz was in the house in custody of Constable Berger, her sister called her attention to a man who was prowling about the barn with a lantern. It was in this barn that the $60,000 stolen from the murdered man was afterward dug up by Detective Stark. The witness saw the man go into the barn once or twice. Afterward he seemed to be approaching the house, but while she was waiting for him to come in he disappeared. She mentioned the incident to Berger, and asked him to go out and make a search, but he made light of it and refused to go. The witness did not mention this affair in her previous testimony.
Bucholz remains cheerful and evidently confident, in marked contrast to his demeanor at the last trial. He watches the proceedings closely, and seems to be no longer oppressed by his old wearing and gloomy anxiety.
BUCHOLZ'S DEFENCE.
----------
Diverting Suspicion to Three Strangers Seen Near the Scene of the Murder.
BRIDGEPORT, April 28. – The principal testimony offered by the defence in the Bucholz trial to-day was in relation to the three strangers seen near the scene of the murder at different times on the day Schulte was killed. It is the aim of the defence to divert suspicion to these men as the real murderers. Two of them were first seen by Benjamin F. Wilcox, at about 7:30 A. M. on the day of the murder, near the South Norwalk depot. One man had dark, bushy whiskers, and both wore good clothes. He saw them again at about 9 A. M., when one of them had on new overalls of a light color. In the latter part of the afternoon he saw them, with a third man, in the fields above South Norwalk. The witness swore, in the cross-examination, that at this time he was in the detective business and on the lookout for suspicious characters.
"Did you ever detect any one who had committed a crime?" asked Mr. Olmstead.
Mr. Wilcox could not say that he had.
His father, Leander G. Wilcox, had also seen three men standing on the railroad bridge below the South Norwalk depot the same morning. His description of them tallied, as far as it went, with the description given by his son. The presence of three strangers in the same locality on the afternoon of the murder was further testified to by Daniel G. Millard and Stephen Ostrander. Millard saw them skulking behind a rock near the foot of the path leading to the Schulte farm. One had dark whiskers and all wore overalls, and were desperate-looking characters. When Mr. Ostrander saw them at the same place and at about the same time two of them were putting on old clothes over good ones. He thought they were disguising themselves because of the dubious quality of the outside garments they were putting on in contrast to their other clothes, and particularly their nice, clean neckwear. He fully corroborated Mr. Millard's statements in regard to their suspicious looks.
The most important testimony regarding these persons was that given by Eli J. Savage, a bright, lively youth of eighteen, living in Norwalk. On his way from South Norwalk down the track, late on the afternoon of the same day, Benjamin Wilcox directed his attention to a dark man with bushy whiskers then crossing the bridge in the direction toward the depot. He visited South Norwalk again in about an hour, and while returning down the track once more the 6:11 train from New York passed him at a crossing below the depot. He stopped as it went by, and saw something white fluttering from a car window. Then a man came up and asked him how long it would take to walk to the next bridge. "Fifteen minutes." replied Savage. The stranger repeated the words in broken English to two men who had joined him in the mean time, adding, "That's just time enough." One of the two later arrivals was the man previously pointed out to the witness by Wilcox. The man who did the questioning next asked if the midnight train stopped at the crossing he had inquired about, and was told that it did not stop this side of Stamford. The man then walked quietly, but rapidly, toward the bridge on which the witness had seen the dark, bushy-whiskered man, and a few minutes later Schulte and Bucholz walked in the same direction on their way home. Young Savage said that while the men stood near him one of them switched around a piece of wire. It was with a wire, Bucholz says, that the scratches were made on his face by one of the murderers.
WITNESS AND PROSECUTOR.
----------
The Uncrushed Savage In the Bucholz Trial Turning upon the State Attorney.
BRIDGEPORT, April 29. – In the Bucholz trial this morning young Savage was cross-examined in regard to the evidence he gave yesterday about seeing and talking with the three desperate-looking and apparently disguised men upon whom the defence is striving to fasten a saving suspicion of being the real murderers of Schulte. In his former argument Mr. Olmstead alluded to the evidence of this witness as an Arabian Nights story. Mr. Olmstead was pretty rough in his treatment of Savage while the latter was testifying, and at length Savage turned to the State Attorney and said: "You have not behaved in a gentlemanly manner toward me. In our first interview you asked me, after hearing my story, if I had manufactured any more evidence, and told me that I didn't know on which side my bread was buttered. You also told me that I didn't know as much as a last year's bird's nest."
"Eli!" retorted Mr. Olmstead with considerable heat, as the witness was quoting the alleged remark about his ignorance regarding the buttered side of the bread; "you know very well that all this is false."
Incidentally, Savage stated that once when making a call upon Gen. Smith he found that gentleman absorbed in playing the banjo. Mr. Olmstead seemed very willing to have this evidence come in, but the Court ruled it out. The evidence given by this witness is the most important of that to be offered by the defence.
This afternoon Conductor Hunt, who ran the 9 o'clock train from New York on the night of the murder, testified that two men, who appeared to be Germans, and one of whom wore a full dark beard, boarded his train at Stamford and paid their fares to New Haven on the cars, although the ticket office was open. Their faces were flushed when they got aboard, and he had the impression that they had been running.
BUCHOLZ'S DEFENCE.
----------
Throwing Susplclon on Two of Schulte's Fellow Passengers from Germany.
BRIDGEPORT, April 30. – The defence in the Bucholz case practically rested this afternoon, Gen. Smith indicating the small importance that he attached to the evidence of the two remaining witnesses on his side by offering to close at the hour of adjournment, provided the State would introduce no rebutting evidence. To this State Attorney Olmstead would not agree.
On the cross-examination of William H. Richards and Charles Strauss, two of the witnesses for the defence, they admitted that when they walked up the railroad track toward South Norwalk, at about 6 o'clock on the night of the murder, they saw nothing of the three men described by young Savage as going down the track from the depot about that time. Mary Downey saw Schulte and Bucholz going down the track on their way home from the depot that night, but did not see anything of the three strangers spoken of by young Savage. Other witnesses have previously testified to seeing three strange men in the fields not far from the scene of the murder, on the afternoon it was committed, but Savage is the only one who claims to have met them on the track.
This afternoon the evidence offered was mainly in regard to the movements of Charles Illing and Morritz Arble, who arrived in New York on the same steamer with Schulte in November, 1878, from Cologne, Germany. The murder was committed in the month following. Cologne, as the defence took special pains to show, is not far from Ehrenweld, where Schulte resided in his native country, and where his brother, to whom he willed his property, now lives. In the same connection to-day Gen. Smith submitted in evidence the murdered man's will, with the statement that his object in doing so was to show who would be benefited by Schulte's death. The testimony of George Wagner. the keeper of a German hotel in this city, was to the effect that Arble came to his house in November, 1878. and remained until the 23d of next month. He went away without paying all of his bill, but left his valise and some clothes as security. From this place Arble went to Schaub's boarding house at South Norwalk. Mr. Schaub thought that Arble did not go out on the night of the murder. but could not be positive. Illing, who claimed to be a detective, stayed with his father-in-law in South Norwalk most of the time he was in this country. Both he and Arble returned to Germany on the May following the murder. Mr. Shaub said that while at his house Arble seemed very eager to get hold of the papers containing an account of the proceedings at the Schulte inquest, but never mentioned the murder in conversation. In the valise which Arble left at Wagner's Hotel was Illing's card and two or three hair brushes similar to those picked up near the scene of the murder. The State tried hard to get these in evidence, but the Court ruled them out.
BUCHOLZ'S LIFE SAVED.
----------
A Verdict of Murder In the Second Degree – Motion Entered for a New Trial.
BRIDGEPORT, May 7. – After being out for forty-seven hours, the jury in the third trial of William Bucholz, for the murder of J. H. Schulte, returned a verdict of murder in the second degree this afternoon. The jury in the first trial were in session about a day and gave a verdict of murder in the first degree, on which Bucholz was sentenced to be hanged. The second jury disagreed, after being out for seventy-nine hours, one of the longest sessions ever held by a criminal jury in this State. They could have agreed upon a second-degree verdict at almost any time but for one member, who insisted upon acquittal. It was expected that the present jury would also disagree, an impression that grew stronger when they failed to reach a verdict after being out all night. They were treated with more than the usual consideration which long deliberating jurymen receive, being marched regularly to a restaurant for their meals, and given the freedom of the court room at night, besides the use of all the spare robes and blankets a neighboring livery stable could furnish. Ten of the twelve jurymen are farmers, and two or three of them look like men of unusual firmness.
When they reported, at 9 o'clock this morning, that they had not yet settled upon a verdict, Judge Beardsley strongly impressed upon them the importance of doing so, reminding them of the expense of money and time attendant upon the three trials, and telling them that they were as well qualified to reach a verdict as any future jury would be. The jury again reported at 3 o'clock, with no verdict. The court inquired about the prospects for one.
"Well," replied the foreman, with a frankness that provoked a general smile, "they would be better if one or two of them would change their views. We haven't made much progress for the last few hours, but I guess we had better try it again for a few minutes, anyway."
They were once more sent out, and in fifteen minutes returned with a verdict of murder in the second degree. Bucholz flushed in the face and flinched a little while the foreman was giving his verdiet, but maintained his sell-possession until his counsel spoke to him kindly and encouragingly a few minutes later. This brought on a prolonged fit of weeping. The compassionate references made to him by his counsel in their arguments affected him in the same way.
Sentence was not pronounced, but under the law it can only be imprisonment for life. His counsel at once made a motion in error and a motion for a new trial, which are to be heard a week from Monday.
The members of the jury refused to inform the reporters about the ballots, saying that they had pledged themselves to secrecy for twenty-four hours. It was learned, however, from other persons with whom they were more communicative, that on the first ballot three voted for acquittal, three for first degree, and six for second degree, It is thought improbable that Bucholz will get a new trial.